Staff Review Date: August 9, 2017 HDC PID#

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "Staff Review Date: August 9, 2017 HDC PID#"

Zoe Green
5 years ago
Views:

1 harlotte Historic istrict ommission pplication for a ertificate of ppropriateness Staff Review ate: ugust 9, 0 H 0-0 PI# 00 LOL HISTORI ISTRIT: PROPERTY RESS: SUMMRY OF REQUEST: PPLINT/OWNER: ilworth 9 East Worthington venue Fenestration changes, porch restoration Zack lsentzer etails of Proposed Request Existing ontext The existing structure is one story ungalow used for commercial/office constructed in 90. The rear yard is a paved parking lot. The building is listed as a non-contributing structure in the ilworth National Register of Historic Places. The building is further described as having a hipped roof with engaged porch which has been bricked up. Project The project is the re-opening of the front porch, new windows, doors and hand rails, and removal of the brick façade for use as a single family house. The rear addition will be reviewed administratively. New materials are wood shake siding, wood trim and matching masonry foundation. On the left side two windows are replaced smaller windows, on the right elevation one window is removed and two casements proposed. The rear yard will be re-established as a residential yard with more open space and landscaping. esign Guidelines - Porches, page.8. Retain porches that are critical to defining the design and integrity of the historic district. Keep porches open to provide shade and reduce heat gain during warm weather.. Repair and replace only damaged elements of porches by matching the materials, methods of construction, and details of the exiting original fabric. void stripping porches and steps of original materials and architectural features such as handrails, balusters, columns and flooring.. Reconstruct missing elements based on physical or photographic detail including all details and materials.. o not enclose porches on a primary elevation or alter a front porch that reorients the entrance away from the street elevation.. Enclosure of side porches and balconies is discouraged. If enclosure of a side porch or balcony is required for a new use, the enclosure should be designed to ensure that the historic character and features of the porch are preserved. 6. ny porch enclosure that is permitted should be designed to be reversible and removal of original features should be minimal. esign Guidelines Replacement Windows, page. 0. Replace entire windows only when they are missing or beyond repair.. To determine if replacement windows are necessary, first survey existing window conditions by noting the number of windows, whether each window is original or replaced, the material, type, hardware and finish, the condition of the frame, sash, sill, putty and panes, in order to clearly gauge the extent of rehabilitation or replacement necessary.

2 . If only the original sash are badly deteriorated, explore using sash replacement kits and retain existing wood window frames. This approach reduces potential damage to the surrounding interior of historic sash.. Maintain the original size and shape of windows. Thin sash frames rarely maintain the overall appearance of historic sash.. Match window replacements to the height and width of the original openings.. Retain the appearance of a double-hung window whether one or both sashes are operable. 6. o not reduce the glass surface area.. Maintain the original number and arrangement of panes. 8. Give depth and profile to windows by using true divided lights, or three-part simulated divided lights with integral spacer bars and interior and exterior fixed muntins. Small variations such as the width and depth of the muntins and sash may be permitted if those variations do not significantly impact the historic characteristics of the window design. lip-in/false muntins, flat muntins and removable external grilles are not allowed. 9. Replace a wood window with a wood window when possible. Wood-resin composite, aluminum-clad wood, or fiberglass windows that meet these guidelines may be considered on a case-by-case basis. Requests for vinyl windows must be reviewed by the full Historic istrict ommission. 0. Use translucent or low-e-glass.. Paint windows in a historically appropriate paint color. Staff nalysis The ommission will determine if the proposal meets the guidelines for porches and fenestration changes, and whether exceptions should be given for windows.

harlotte Historic istrict ommission ase 0-0 HISTORI ISTRIT: ILWORTH FRONT FE HNGES amden Rd E Kingston v South v leveland v East v E Worthington v Euclid v

3 harlotte Historic istrict ommission ase 0-0 HISTORI ISTRIT: ILWORTH FRONT FE HNGES amden Rd E Kingston v South v leveland v East v E Worthington v Euclid v therton Heights Ln E Tremont v Feet July 8, 0 Lyndhurst v 9 E. Worthington v ilworth Historic istrict Property Lines uilding Footprints Winthrop v

5 60 EST WORTHINGTON VENUE - RER YR PERMEILITY LS 9 RE ESRIPTION SQFT RES RER YR RE MIN. PERMELE SURFE REQ' ROOFS, WLKS, SHES S ESIGNE PERMELE S ESIGNE 6 sqft 8 sqft 869 sqft 6 sqft % LULTIONS 00% 0% % 8% FROM RER OF, W/O LLEY MIN. PERMELE (OPEN) REQ' OVERE SURFE RE ESIGNE PERMELE (OPEN) S ESIGNE '-" LWN LRGE TREE TO REMIN. G TO PROVIE ROOT PROTETION URING ONSTRUTION, TYP 8 Logie venue harlotte, N 80 ph: 0..6 REMOVE GRVEL LOT, REPLE W/ LWN N/OR LNSPING r 9 E Worthington ve MSTER TH '"x0'" PTIO '8"x9'8" 9 E. Worthington ve / 00 File Name: 00_EWorthingtonve.vwx rawings and their contents are property of:. o not reproduce or distribute without written consent from. and Zacharias K. lsentzer, R, LEE P. opyright 0. '-0" PTIO 8'-0" GREN ch GRVEL PRKING - NOT9 FOR ONSTRUTION - MSTER E '"x6'" INING '0"x0'0" EVERGREEN SHRUS, T OUNTER EPTH FRIGE KITHEN '6"x'" W.I.. '"x9'0" LUNRY 6'0"x'6" HV N UTILITIES INITES EXTENT OF HIP ROOF TH 9'"x'0" E '"x'6" GLLERY '0"x0'9" OFFIE / E '8"x9'6" SHRE GRVEL RIVEWY LIVING '6"x6'6" PORH '"x9'" UILT-IN ENH SET ate escription 0 08/6/0 H Review REPIR/REPLE ONRETE WLKWY, VIF Site Plan & Survey Property Survey Scale: '=0' Site Plan FT Scale: " = 0 ft 00

FRONT ELEVTION 8 Logie venue harlotte, N 80 ph: 0.

Worthington ve / 00 File Name: 00_EWorthingtonve.vwx rawings and their contents are property of:.

6 FRONT ELEVTION 8 Logie venue harlotte, N 80 ph: 0..6 PINTE ER SHKE SIING - NOT9 FOR ONSTRUTION - 9 E Worthington ve EXTERIOR SIING, MTH, VIF 9 E. Worthington ve / 00 File Name: 00_EWorthingtonve.vwx rawings and their contents are property of:. o not reproduce or distribute without written consent from. and Zacharias K. lsentzer, R, LEE P. opyright 0. 0 GUGE LUMINUM FLSHING, EXTEN 6" UP WLL N OVER SING TRIM, P, N OVE MOULING, MTH ETILS, VIF SING TRIM, MTH PROFILE N ETIL(S), VIF /8" LTTIE, MTH ETILS, TYP PINTE WOO WINOW TO MTH, VIF OUTSIE INSIE X SILL, LER N RIE WESTERN RE ER WITH RIP UT. SLOPE TOP, MTH PROFILE N ETIL, VIF /" STOOL, MTH, VIF X SKIRT, MTH, VIF ate escription 0 08/6/0 H Review EXTERIOR SIING, MTH, VIF RIK FE TO E REMOVE Material etails WINOW TRIM ETIL Existing onditions Window etail - Typical Scale: " = '-0" 0

7 8 Logie venue harlotte, N 80 ph: 0..6 WINOW H HT '-" - NOT FOR ONSTRUTION - REMOVE RIK FE 9 E Worthington ve RER ELEVTION SLE: /" = '-0" ELEVTIONS FRONT ELEVTION SLE: /" = '-0" File Name: Worthington Remodel / 00 9_EastWorthingtonve rawings and their contents are property of:. o not reproduce or distribute without written consent from. and Zacharias K. lsentzer, R, LEE P. opyright 0. PROPOSE ELEVTIONS RIK HIMNEY'S NEW WOO RKET TO MTH RHITETURL SPHLT TO MTH NEW WOO WINOWS N TRIM TO MTH RIK HIMNEY'S SPHLT SHINGLES WOO FSI OR (PINT) WOO SHKES TO MTH (PINT) PINTE WOO FSI OR PINTE OXE/TRIME RHITETURL EM WOO PERGOL (PINT) NEW WOO N GLSS I-FOLING OORS RIK KNEE WLL WITH ONRETE P MU FOUNTION WLL W/ RIK VENEER TO MTH WINOW HE (TYP) '-" 8" SQURE PINTE WOO OLUMN; SEE ETIL ON 0 PINTE WOO RILING W/ X PIKETS " O.. STINE WOO T&G EKING W/ PINTE WOO TRIM N WOO HNRIL RIK STIRS ate escription 0 08/6/0 H Review MU FOUNTION WLL W/ RIK VENEER TO MTH RER ELEVTION SLE: /" = '-0" FRONT ELEVTION SLE: /" = '-0" Front and Rear Elevations Existing and Proposed 0

8 8 Logie venue harlotte, N 80 ph: 0..6 WINOW HE HEIGHT '-" - NOT FOR ONSTRUTION - REMOVE RIK FE LEFT SIE ELEVTION SLE: /" = '-0" 9 E Worthington ve ELEVTION File Name: Worthington ve Remodel / 00 9_EastWorthingtonve rawings and their contents are property of:. o not reproduce or distribute without written consent from. and Zacharias K. lsentzer, R, LEE P. opyright 0. PROPOSE ELEVTION NEW RHITETURL SPHLT TO MTH WOO FSI OR (PINT) WOO PERGOL (PINT) ate escription WINOW HE HEIGHT '-" WOO SHKES TO MTH (PINT) RIK KNEE WLL WITH ONRETE P NEW WOO FRME WINOW NEW WOO GURRIL W/ X PIKETS; SEE /0 FOR ITIONL INFORMTION PINTE WOO RKET ETIL NEW RIK STIRS 0 08/6/0 H Review MU FOUNTION WLL W/ RIK VENEER TO MTH LEFT SIE ELEVTION SLE: /" = '-0" Left Side Elevation Existing and Proposed 0

N WTER SHIEL UNERLYMENT WINOW HE HEIGHT '-" PROVIE LOKING S REQ' " ROUN SOFFIT VENT W/ SREENING ENTERE ETWEEN EVERY OTHER RFTER WOO SHKES OVE EM METL EVE FLSHING W/ RIP EGE LPS FSI.

9 N WTER SHIEL UNERLYMENT WINOW HE HEIGHT '-" PROVIE LOKING S REQ' " ROUN SOFFIT VENT W/ SREENING ENTERE ETWEEN EVERY OTHER RFTER WOO SHKES OVE EM METL EVE FLSHING W/ RIP EGE LPS FSI. NO GUTTER PINTE WOO FSI N EXPOSE RFTER TILS 0" TRIM N W/ TOP P '-0 /" /" 0 /" FRMING; SEE STRUTURL PORH EM; SEE STRUTURL PINTE/STINE EOR PORH EILING PINTE OXE/TRIME RHITETURL EM 8" SQURE PINTE WOO OLUMN W/ SE N PITL TRIM S SHOWN 8 Logie venue harlotte, N 80 ph: '-0" '-6" /" SHE LINE INITES ONELE OLUMN; SEE STRUTURL - NOT FOR ONSTRUTION - REMOVE RIK FE RIGHT SIE ELEVTION SLE: /" = '-0" ELEVTION PROPOSE ELEVTION X PINTE WOO TRIM N /" '- /" /" PINTE WOO RILING EYON; X PIKETS SPE " MX W/ X TOP N OTTOM RILS ON OTH FES W/ ROWNE X P STINE T&G WOO EKING ON PORH FLOOR FRMING. PROVIE /" PER " SLOPE TO RIN.SEE STRUTURL. PROVIE VENTING UNER PORH VITY PER LULTIONS, VIF PROVIE VPOR RRIER 9 E Worthington ve File Name: Worthington ve Remodel / 00 9_EastWorthingtonve rawings and their contents are property of:. o not reproduce or distribute without written consent from. and Zacharias K. lsentzer, R, LEE P. opyright 0. MU FOUNTION WLL W/ RIK VENEER TO MTH, VIF, SEE STRUTURL ONRETE FOOTING; SEE STRUTURL NEW SETION ETIL T PORH OLUMN SLE: /" = '-0" RHITETURL SPHLT TO MTH WOO FSI OR (PINT) NEW WOO OXE EM; SEE /0 FOR ITIONL INFORMTION RHITETURL SPHLT TO MTH WOO PERGOL (PINT) ate escription WOO SHKES TO MTH (PINT) WINOW HE HEIGHT '-" NEW WOO WINOW N FRME TO MTH NEW 8" WOO OXE OLUMN; SEE /0 FOR ITIONL INFORMTION NEW RIK STIRS NEW WOO GURRIL W/ X PIKETS; SEE /0 FOR ITIONL INFORMTION WOO SHKES TO MTH (PINT) NEW WOO FRME WINOW RIK KNEE WLL WITH ONRETE P 0 08/6/0 H Review Right Side Elevation Existing and Proposed STINE T&G WOO EKING W/ PINTE WOO TRIM N RIGHT SIE ELEVTION SLE: /" = '-0" 0

10 MSTER TH '"x0'" PTIO '8"x9'8" 8 Logie venue harlotte, N 80 ph: NOT 9 FOR ONSTRUTION - N 6" SILL 88" HE 6" SILL 88" HE STOR. KITHEN 9'- /" EILING '-0 /" T LNG HIMNEY ROOM 9'- /" EILING '-0 /" T LNG 6" SILL 88" HE 9 E Worthington ve File Name: 9 E. Worthington ve / 00 00_EWorthingtonve.vwx rawings and their contents are property of:. o not reproduce or distribute without written consent from. and Zacharias K. lsentzer, R, LEE P. opyright 0. STOR. '-" MSTER E '"x6'" INING '0"x0'0" 0'-" 8" 8" LINE OF W.I.. '"x9'0" LUNRY 6'0"x'6" KITHEN '6"x'" OUNTER EPTH FRIGE TTI ESS TOILET & STORGE 6" SILL 88" HE ROOM 9'- /" EILING '-0 /" T LNG FIREPLE HV ROOM 9'- /" EILING '-0 /" T LNG 6" SILL 80" HE 6" SILL 88" HE PROPOSE E '"x'6" TH 9'"x'0" GLLERY '0"x0'9" LIVING '6"x6'6" WH 6" SILL 88" HE LOSET ROOM 9'- /" EILING '-0 /" T LNG ROOM 9'- /" EILING '-0 /" T LNG HV STORGE 86" HE FOYER 9'- /" EILING '-0 /" T LNG 6" SILL 88" HE /" SILL 8" HE HETE RE (SQFT) OFFIE / E '8"x9'6" PORH '"x9'" 9'-0 /" ate escription 0 08/6/0 H Review " SILL 6" HE N 9 PROPOSE 66 '-8" EQ UILT-IN ENH SET 8'-0" EQ Floor Plans '- /" '-" First Floor Existing Floor Plan Scale: /" = '-0" First Floor Plan Scale: /" = '-0" FT 0

Staff Review Date: September 13, 2017 HDC PID#

Staff Review Date: September 13, 2017 HDC PID# harlotte Historic istrict ommission pplication for a ertificate of ppropriateness Staff Review ate: September, 07 H 07-6 PI# 087 LOL HISTORI ISTRIT: PROPERTY RESS: SUMMRY OF REQUEST: PPLINT: ilworth 60