A Roadmap for Commercializing Microgrids in California

Transcription

1 A Roadmap for Commercializing Microgrids in California October 2, 2017 Mike Gravely California Energy Commission Jose Aliaga-Caro California Public Utilities Commission Peter Klauer California Independent Systems Operator

2 Purpose of the Workshop Review the work completed to date Review results of Energy Commission funded microgrid research designed to support the development of the Microgrid Roadmap Review results of Energy Commission funded microgrid research survey designed to support the development of the Microgrid Roadmap Review the Draft Microgrid Roadmap posted on September 29, 2017 Discuss the action times and the priorities that should be assigned to each Discuss process to obtain and incorporate recommended changes and improvements from workshop participants into the Draft Roadmap Discuss next steps in finalizing and Publishing the Microgrid Roadmap 2

3 Agenda 10:00 Opening Comments: CPUC CAISO Energy Commission Jose Aliaga-Caro Peter Klauer/Kristina Osborne Mike Gravely 10:15 Recap of the Earlier Microgrid Mike Gravely Workshops 10:25 Results of Navigant Microgrid Study Adam Forni Navigant Consulting 11:00 Results from Microgrid Internet Jeff Root Survey Ecotech Resources 3

4 Agenda 11:30am Review Draft Microgrid Roadmap Mike Gravely Jose Aliaga-Caro Peter Klauer Topic: Overview of Draft Roadmap Topic: Key Issues Facing Commercializing Microgrids in California Noon 1pm Lunch Break 4

5 Agenda 1:00pm Return from Lunch All 1:05pm Review Draft Microgrid Roadmap Mike Gravely Jose Aliaga-Caro Peter Klauer Topic: Key Issues Facing Commercialization Microgrids in California 2:00pm Review Draft Microgrid Roadmap Mike Gravely Jose Aliaga-Caro Peter Klauer Topic: Microgrid Roadmap Action Items 5

6 Agenda 3:00pm Review Draft Microgrid Roadmap Mike Gravely Jose Aliaga-Caro Peter Klauer Topic: Any Recommended New Sections to the Draft Roadmap 3:20pm Public Comment All 3:45pm Steps in Finalizing the Microgrid Roadmap Mike Gravely 4:00pm Adjourn All 6

7 Agenda Recap of the Earlier Microgrid Workshops Mike Gravely 7

8 8

9

10 Review of Draft Roadmap 10

11 Review of Draft Roadmap Overall Understanding of the Roadmap: Purpose of the Roadmap What is possible in the future How will the Roadmap be used How can you improve the Roadmap while in draft form What are the future opportunities to implement the Roadmap 11

12 Chapter 1 Why Microgrids are Important to California What is a Microgrid What can Microgrids Accomplish What is the value of Microgrids 12

13 Chapter 2 Key Issues Facing Commercializing Microgrids in California How Microgrids Operate and their value Improving the Electric Grid with Microgrids How Microgrids Can Play a Role in Implementing the State s Policy Goals Microgrids can Increase the Penetration of Renewables on the California grid Microgrids can Support California's Policy to Permit High Concentration of DERs on the Grid How Do Microgrids Operate in the Current California Regulatory Framework? Emerging Role of State Regulation in Microgrid Development Technical Challenges Facing Microgrids Understanding the Economics of Microgrids 13

14 Microgrid Operation and Value Chapter 3 Roadmap Actions 1. Develop non-proprietary, publicly available educational and guidance materials for microgrids. 2. Develop, evaluate, and publish improved metrics to assess microgrid system performance. 3. Complete research that defines the building blocks necessary to implement microgrids from start to finish. 14

15 Chapter 3 Roadmap Actions Improving the Electric Grid with Microgrids 1. Develop methods to reduce cost barriers for microgrid participation in grid services requiring special metering and telemetry equipment. 2. Clarify the microgrid participation rules and requirements to provide multiple revenue streams. Where possible, leverage the rules and requirements being developed for the energy storage industry or other DER systems. 3. Develop and validate new benefit metrics for system resiliency that are provided by microgrids. 15

16 Chapter 3 Roadmap Actions Microgrids Role to Implement State s Policy Goals 1. Develop different microgrid use cases that will support increased penetrations of renewables on the California electric grid. 2. Develop state level strategies to open wholesale and retail markets to microgrids that will support California s future energy policy goals. 3. Facilitate opportunities to work with California Tribal Communities and other special entities that want to include future microgrids in their utility operations. 4. Complete detailed research studies and analysis on the role microgrids play in California utilities to meet future policy goals. 5. Define the role of microgrids in future grid management with higher concentrations of DERs. 16

17 Microgrid Technical Challenges Chapter 3 Roadmap Actions 1. Develop and publish new processes and procedures where existing and future microgrids can provide publicly available lessons learned from fielded and operating microgrids. 2. Complete research to identify new opportunities for potential economic revenue streams for microgrids for services they can provide their owner/operator, the utilities, and the California ISO. 3. Develop a process to reduce the risks and problems of microgrid islanding. 4. Prepare guidelines to assist local government agencies and others in selecting and supporting future microgrid projects. 17

18 Microgrid Technical Challenges Chapter 3 Roadmap Actions 5. Evaluate how microgrids can provide new options to address the impacts of the aging California natural gas infrastructure. 6. Define minimum cybersecurity requirements for microgrids. 7. Analyze and compare the commercial viability of different microgrid configurations. 8. Fund technical research to address current regulatory issues facing microgrid deployments. 18

19 Chapter 3 Roadmap Actions How Microgrids Operate in the Current California Regulatory Framework 1. Develop microgrid service standards necessary to meet state and local permitting requirements. 2. Develop methods to reduce cost barriers for microgrid interconnection requirements. 3. Develop guidelines that determine what impact studies are required for microgrids to connect to the utility grid. 4. Determine if separate utility rates and tariffs are necessary to support microgrids. 5. Form a working group to codify standards and protocols needed to meet California utility and California ISO microgrid requirements. 19

20 Economics of Microgrids Chapter 3 Roadmap Actions 1. Develop and validate new benefit metrics for the system reliability provided by microgrids. 2. Enact the state approved rules under which microgrids can participate in wholesale and retail markets. 3. Define different revenue streams available to microgrids beyond the ones that currently exist, such as volt-amp reactive (VAR) services, flexible energy services, and emergency services. 20

21 Recommended New Sections to the Draft Roadmap: 1. Chapter 1: Why Microgrids are Important to California 2. Chapter 2: Key Issues Facing Commercializing Microgrids in California 3. Chapter 3: Roadmap Actions 21

22 Steps in Finalizing the Microgrid Roadmap Review Comments and Discussions from Oct 2 nd Workshop Review Comments that Come in by October 20 th Determine if an additional WebEx Workshop is needed Agencies complete internal reviews of Proposed Draft Roadmap Agencies Publish Microgrid Roadmap 22

23 Written comments: This workshop is using an electronic commenting system for submitting written comments. Stakeholders wishing to submit comments should complete the form provided on the EPIC docket webpage at: x?docketnumber=16-epic-01. Written comments should be submitted by 5:00 p.m. on October 20, All written comments will become part of the public record of this proceeding. 23

24 The Energy Commission encourages use of its electronic commenting system, but written comments may also be submitted by ing them to the Dockets Office, or by U.S. Mail to: California Energy Commission Dockets Office, MS-4 Re: Docket No. 16-EPIC Ninth Street Sacramento, CA If you choose not to use the electronic filing system, please include the docket number 16-EPIC-01 on any ed or written comments. Comments may be ed to 24

25 Questions 25

26 Closing Comments 26