Star Trek and Religion: Changing attitudes towards religion in Voyager and DS9

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "Star Trek and Religion: Changing attitudes towards religion in Voyager and DS9"

Berniece Short
6 years ago
Views:

1 Star Trek and Religion: Changing attitudes towards religion Changing DS9, Voyager attitudes and towards Enterprise religion in Voyager and DS9

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Differences between DS9 and other Trek series: Takes place on space station (repeated contact with different species, not just perepisode contact

2 Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Differences between DS9 and other Trek series: Takes place on space station (repeated contact with different species, not just perepisode contact deeper cultural understanding? Religion central to premise, multiple episodes Regular worship events featured: prayers, temple attendance, meditation, religious hierarchy, etc.

3 Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Does DS9 as a series respect religion? What factors might indicate that it does respect religion? What factors might indicate it does not? Were we more open to the spiritual in the late 1990 s then we were in the 1980 s (or 1960 s), or less so? Is respect another way of saying patronizing rejection?

The most significant religious story arc in DS9 (and/or any Trek series to date) is that of Sisko s religious journey from sceptical humanist to religious emissary.

4 The most significant religious story arc in DS9 (and/or any Trek series to date) is that of Sisko s religious journey from sceptical humanist to religious emissary. Sisko s divine parentage :revealed in Season Seven, Sisko s mother was human, possessed by Bajoran Prophet Mother left after Sisko born - mission accomplished! Sisko is therefore sort-of, in a sci-fi way, of divine parentage - brought to life deliberately by beings worshipped as Gods. First time ever gods are shown to act outside the species to whom they are sacred What does this say about Star Trek: DS9 s treatment of the divine? Is this a more sympathetic treatment than Classic Trek or Next Gen? Star Trek: Deep Space Nine

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Sisko s Journey Identified as the Emissary by spiritual leader of Bajor in the pilot episode ( Emissary 1993) Religious role accepted

5 Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Sisko s Journey Identified as the Emissary by spiritual leader of Bajor in the pilot episode ( Emissary 1993) Religious role accepted reluctantly, but only as subordinate to Starfleet secular way of understanding ( Destiny 1995; Accession 1996) Truly accepts his religious role in fifth season - ( Rapture 1997)

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Sisko s Journey, con t Starfleet role and Emissary role come into conflict in sixth season - Sisko chooses Starfleet role, and disaster follows ( Tears of the Prophets

6 Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Sisko s Journey, con t Starfleet role and Emissary role come into conflict in sixth season - Sisko chooses Starfleet role, and disaster follows ( Tears of the Prophets 1998) Season seven (final season) - Sisko follows spiritual path, fulfils destiny - religious journey compete. ( Image in the Sand 1999; What you leave behind 1999) see 10 minute clip Comes to wife Kassidy in a vision - has now transcended physical limits, linear time

Is he living bodily in Celestial Temple?

7 Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Apotheosis - ascending to godhood. Multiple interpretations possible (but mine is the right one!!) Did Sisko die? Is he living bodily in Celestial Temple? What more do the Prophets have for Sisko to do? Is Sisko a god? A prophet? A servant of the prophets?

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine The Conversion of Kassidy Kassidy is Sisko s wife, married against Prophet s advice Represents secular Starfleet view Refuses to accept

8 Star Trek: Deep Space Nine The Conversion of Kassidy Kassidy is Sisko s wife, married against Prophet s advice Represents secular Starfleet view Refuses to accept Sisko as Emmissary until pregnant, then converts to religious view When Kassidy comes to accept Sisko as Emmisary, viewing audience does also? Recipient of vision of Sisko

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Sisko s religious journey has New Age elements: monistic ( for one moment I glimpsed it all, the pattern that held it all together.

9 Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Sisko s religious journey has New Age elements: monistic ( for one moment I glimpsed it all, the pattern that held it all together... ) purposeful ( I m their emissary, and they are not finished with me yet... ) individualistic - Sisko s religious journey is his own - others need not follow same path in order to have genuine religious experiences (i.e. Klingons, other Bajorans, Vulcans...) evolutionary - Sisko is evolving into something god-like - other humans can/will follow suit Millenial - cosmic battle of good/evil - good wins

10 Star Trek: Voyager Number of Star Trek firsts: first female captain; inversion of previous gender norms (TNG vs VOY); first female engineer 1st time human being shown to be religious 1st native american character Native American Spirituality as a model for religion

11 Star Trek: Voyager Native American spirituality in Voyager Spirit guides Vision quests Soul travel Healing rituals Environmental concerns

12 Star Trek: Voyager False God theme revisited - Sky gods = aliens Sympathetic approach Integration of science and spirituality? New age connection Episode Tattoo 1996

13 Star Trek: Voyager New Age Elements in Voyager: rationality (in accord with science, empirical) pluralism/eclecticism (many paths) humanism (spirituality located in human potential - evolutionary) individualism (each individual defines reality for themselves)

14 Star Trek: Voyager Religion/Science - is faith in Science religious? Episode: Sacred Ground Leap of Faith Non-rational Construct own reality

15 Star Trek: Voyager Do religion and science have to be opposed? Can Science provide access to spiritual experiences? Episode: Omega Directive

16 Star Trek: Enterprise Episode Chosen Realm - religious fanatics as terrorists, religious motivation = no win situation? D Jamat: What s wrong? Yarrick: We ve just begun this mission, and already, three people are dead. D Jamat: And that bothers you Yarrick: Shouldn t it?!...these people are not our enemy! D Jamat: They are non-believers...that makes them our enemy! Archer: These people you re fighting... what makes them heretics? Yarrick: We believe the Makers created the Chosen Realm in nine days. They believe it took ten. Archer: For that, you ve been at war for over a century?! Archer: As long as people like D Jamat dictate what s true and what isn t... all you ll ever have is war.

17 Star Trek: Enterprise Vulcan Reformation story arc - The Forge, Awakening, and Kir Shara (2005) Protestant, Christianinformed view of religion Back to the bible (Kir shara) emphasis Personal experience Revelation Reformation of corrupt teachings

18 Star Trek and Religion How has Star Trek changed in its attitudes towards religion over the years? Does Star Trek reflect societal attitudes, or does it stand in opposition to them, when it comes to religion? Is Star Trek s secular, rational worldview the norm for contemporary media? Contemporary society? Will we outgrow religion? Will we embrace the kind of rationalized, individualized religion Star Trek seems to advocate?

Star Trek and Religion: Changing attitudes towards religion Changing Voyager attitudes towards and DS9religion in Voyager and DS9

Star Trek and Religion: Changing attitudes towards religion Changing Voyager attitudes towards and DS9religion in Voyager and DS9 Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Differences between DS9 and other Trek series: