arxiv: v1 [cs.it] 22 Jul 2014

Transcription

1 MODULATION FORMATS AND WAVEFORMS FOR THE PHYSICAL LAYER OF 5G WIRELESS NETWORKS: WHO WILL BE THE HEIR OF OFDM? Paoo Banei, Stefano Buzzi, Giuio Coavope, Andrea Modenini, Fredrik Rusek, and Aessandro Ugoini arxiv: v1 [cs.it] 22 Ju G ceuar communications promise to deiver the gigabit experience to mobie users, with a capacity increase of up to three orders of magnitude with respect to current LTE systems. There is widespread agreement that such an ambitious goa wi be reaized through a combination of innovative techniques invoving different network ayers. At the physica ayer, the OFDM moduation format, aong with its mutipe-access strategy OFDMA, is not taken for granted, and severa aternatives promising arger vaues of spectra efficiency are being considered. This paper provides a review of some moduation formats suited for 5G, enriched by a comparative anaysis of their performance in a ceuar environment, and by a discussion on their interactions with specific 5G ingredients. The interaction with a massive MIMO system is aso discussed by empoying rea channe measurements. INTRODUCTION Orthogona frequency division mutipexing (OFDM) and orthogona frequency division mutipe access (OFDMA) are the moduation technique and the mutipe access strategy adopted in ong term evoution (LTE) 4G ceuar network standards, respectivey [1]. OFDM and OFDMA succeeded to code division mutipe access (CDMA), empoyed in 3G networks, for severa reasons such as, to cite some, the ease of impementation of both transmitter and receiver thanks to the use of fast Fourier transform (FFT) and inverse fast Fourier transform (IFFT) bocks, the abiity to counteract muti-path distortion, the orthogonaity of subcarriers which eiminates interce interference, the possibiity of adapting, the transmitted power and the moduation cardinaity, and the ease of integration with muti-antenna hardware, both at the transmitter and receiver. Nonetheess, despite such a poo of positive properties, OFDM/OFDMA are not exempt of defects, and their adoption in the forthcoming generation of wireess networks is not taken for granted. Indeed, the spectra efficiency of OFDM is imited by the need of a cycic prefix and by its arge side-obes (which require some nu guard tones at the spectrum edges), OFDM signas may exhibit arge peakto-average-power ratio vaues [2], and the impossibiity of having strict frequency synchronization among subcarriers makes OFDM and OFDMA not reay orthogona techniques. In particuar, synchronization is a key issue in the upink of a ceuar network wherein different mobie terminas transmit separatey [3], and, aso, in the downink when base station coordination is used [4, 5]. For instance, with regard to the spectra efficiency oss of side-obes and the cycic prefix (CP), in an LTE system operating at 10 MHz bandwidth, ony 9 MHz of the band is in fact used. In addition, the oss of the CP is around 7%, so the accumuated oss totas at 16%. These drawbacks, which invaidate many of the above discussed OFDM/OFDMA advantages, form the basis of an open and intense debate on what the moduation format and mutipe access strategy shoud be in next generation ceuar networks. 5G ceuar systems wi feature severa innovative strategies with respect to existing LTE systems, incuding, among others, extensive adoption of sma ces, use of mm-wave communications for short-range inks, arge scae antenna arrays instaed on macro base stations, coud-based radio access network, and, possiby, opportunistic expoitation of spectrum hoes through a cognitive approach [6]. A these strategies wi be impacted by the moduation format used at the physica ayer. At the same time, 5G ceuar networks wi have more stringent requirements than LTE in terms of atency, energy efficiency and data rates, which again are impacted by the adopted moduation scheme. This paper provides a review of some of the most credited aternatives to OFDM, performs a critica mutua comparison in terms of spectra efficiency, and discusses their possibe interactions with the cited technoogies and requirements of 5G networks. The focus of the paper is on inear moduations and, after a quick review of OFDM, the emphasis is shifted on fiterbank muticarrier, time-frequency packing, and singe-carrier moduations. Particuary we wi focus on spectra efficiency empoying quite a genera signa processing framework couped with an information theoretic approach, which permits evauating the practica information rate associated with a specific signa format. The aim indeed is far away to be exhaustive with respect to a the possibe impementation issues and scenarios, sti highighting possibe research directions and approaches that deserve to be further investigated. The paper is aso enriched by a specific section on massive MIMO systems, and by a performance study based on rea channe measurements from a massive MIMO testbed from Lund University.

2 SYSTEM MODEL For a the moduation formats considered in this work, the compex baseband equivaent of the transmitted signa, say x(t), can be expressed as x(t) = P T s G = G s (t T s ). (1) In the above equation, P is the signa power, T s is the symbo period, 2G + 1 is the number of tempora sots spanned by each data packet, and the waveform s (t) is the compex baseband equivaent of the waveform associated to the -th tempora sot [7, 8], and is written as s (t) = 1 N 1 d k, p(t)e j2πk δ f δ t Ts (t+ts). (2) N k=0 In (2), N is the number of subcarriers, d k, is the transmitted symbo associated with the (k, )-th resource eement (that is, k-th subcarrier and -th symbo interva), p(t) is the underying shaping puse, δ t and δ f are two dimensioness constants that rue the actua time and frequency spacing among the transmitted symbos d k,. In particuar, etting T be a reference symbo time used for normaization and defined as T = Ts δ t, it is seen that symbos d k, are spaced in time by T s = δ t T and in frequency by δ f δ t T s = δ f T. Note that etting δ f = δ t = 1 we obtain the usua orthogonaity-preserving frequency spacing 1/T which hods for OFDM systems, whie the dimensioness product δ f δ t can be interpreted as a measure of how much symbos are packed with respect to the cassica OFDM choice [8, 9, 10]. Combining (1) and (2) we aso obtain x(t) = P Ts N N 1 G k=0 = G d k, p(t T s )e j2πk δ f δ t Ts t. (3) Note aso that the shaping puse p(t) has no restrictions in its (practicay finite) time duration, but it is assumed to be of unit energy, i.e., p(t) 2 = 1. Moreover, as specified ater, variabes {d k, }, the transmitted symbos, are not necessariy equa to pure moduation symbos as they may incude some form of signa processing, which for instance aows to consider other (staggered) attice structures. The pure data symbos are denoted by {a k, }, which we assume to be of unit average power, i.e., E[ a k, 2 ] = 1. Now, it is easy to show that the above signa mode is representative of severa moduation formats. OFDM. Cassica OFDM systems assume p(t) as a rectanguar puse of duration T s = T + T cp, where T cp is the CP duration. Consequenty, δ t = 1 + T cp /T and δ f = 1 to grant orthogonaity on the usefu symbo duration T. Note that the transmitted symbos d k, at the edge bands can be set to zero to imit out-of-band emissions. We aso reca here that OFDM is the moduation format used in the downink of current LTE systems, whereas for the upink an OFDM variant known as singe-carrier FDMA (SC-FDMA) is adopted, in order to imit the peak-to-average power ratio (PAPR) [1]. Fiterbank muticarrier (FBMC). FBMC is an OFDM-ike moduation format wherein subcarriers are passed through fiters that suppress signas sideobes, making them eventuay stricty bandimited. The transmitter and receiver may sti be impemented through FFT/IFFT bocks or poyphase fiter structures [8, 9], and bandimitedness may deiver arger spectra efficiency than OFDM. The use of FBMC for 5G ceuar networks is mainy endorsed for its abiity (due to signa bandimitedness) to cope with network asynchronicity that naturay arises in the upink and/or in the downink with coordinated transmission [11], for its greater robustness to frequency misaignments among users when compared to OFDM [12], and for its more fexibe expoitation of frequency white spaces in cognitive radio networks [6, 8]. FBMC is usuay either couped with QAM or with Offset- QAM (OQAM) moduation formats. For FBMC-QAM, we have δ t δ f 1 and the transmitted symbos d k, = a k, are drawn from an M-ary QAM consteation. For FBMC- OQAM, instead, symbos are haf-spaced in time with respect to FBMC-QAM, and consequenty we have δ t δ f 0.5. The transmitted symbos are reated to the data symbos by the reation d k, = j k+ a k,, and the data symbos a k, are rea-vaued M-ary PAM symbos. Faster-than-Nyquist (FTN) / Time-frequency-packed (TFS) signaing. Faster-than-Nyquist (FTN) signaing, first discussed by Mazo as eary as 1975 in [13], is a technique to increase the spectra efficiency of a communication system by etting δ t < 1, thus introducing intentiona interference among data symbos at the transmitter side. FTN was for a ong time studied ony as a singe carrier technique [14], and over time it stood cear that FTN can expoit the excess bandwidth of the singe carrier signa. The rate gains of FTN in singe carrier systems spurred a number of extensions of FTN into muticarrier setups [15, 16, 17, 18, 19], and the resuting moduation formats have aso been named as Timefrequency-packed signaing (TFS). Let us first ay down the mode for the transmitted signa of TFS. The system mode we use is a generaized version of either an FBMC-OQAM mode or an FBMC-QAM mode. In view of (3), the TFS system has a parameters identica to its FBMC counterpart except for the product δ t δ f. When an FBMC-OQAM system underies the TFS system, this product shoud satisfy δ t δ f < 0.5, whie for an underying FBMC-QAM system it satisfies δ t δ f < 1. More sophisticated arguments, inspired by time-frequency anaysis, highight how these communication systems are based on Wey-Heisenberg function sets, aso known as Gabor sets [20, 7], and as specia cases of packing data on a Grassmannian manifod [21]. Arguments on data packing theory [9, 21], indicate that the best packing is

3 obtained by hexagona attices, which provide some spectra efficiency gains with respect to rectanguar, or staggered, attices. For simpicity we wi not consider this specia case, athough the genera framework derived herein, as we as the concusions, can be easiy extended. Singe-carrier moduation (SCM) Letting N = 1, the outined signa mode bois down to a inear singe carrier moduation format. During recent times, muticarrier systems have been the dominant moduation format, the main reason being that optima equaization can be efficienty carried out in the frequency domain, whie optima equaization of a singe carrier system is much more invoved and essentiay requires the use of a Viterbi agorithm. Recenty, however, there has been regained interest in singe carrier techniques due to the deveopment of high-performance and ow-compexity equaizers operating in the frequency domain [22, 23, 24]. In this paper, we sha consider a singe carrier structure adopting a CP in order to provide an interbock interference free system and to convert the channe into a cycic convoution, which simpifies the usage of the frequency domain equaizer, especiay in time-invariant or sowy-varying channes. If the time duration of the channe impuse response is at most T ch seconds, and the symbo time is T s, then the cycic prefix needs to be at east G cp = T ch /T s symbos ong. Hence, in the data bock in (1), ony 2G + 1 G cp symbos d k, corresponds to data symbos, whie the other G cp represent the redundancy of the cycic prefix. Tabe 1 provides an overview of the vaues of the parameters characterizing the discussed moduations formats. SPECTRAL EFFICIENCY When assessing the performance of a given moduation and coding system, a key figure of merit is the spectra efficiency ρ, defined as ρ = R cnζ g og 2 (M) T s W tot b/s/hz where R c is the rate of the empoyed channe code, W tot is the tota frequency occupancy of the signa according to some measure, and ζ g 1 is the inefficiency due to possibe guard bands in muticarrier systems, or duay, guard time in singe carrier systems. We remind the reader that M denotes the cardinaity of the empoyed moduation, and N is the number of subcarriers. Note that spectra efficiency denotes here the data-rate that can be transmitted for each bandwidth unit used for transmission, regardess of the underying bit error rate (BER). Later on, instead, we wi focus on the achievabe spectra efficiency (ASE), a much more insightfu performance measure, representing the spectra efficiency which a system may attain under the constraint of arbitrariy sma BER. For OFDM, with an M-ary QAM (M-QAM) consteation, the spectra efficiency has expression ρ OFDM = R cnζ g og 2 (M) N + G cp b/s/hz. Regarding FBMC, with an M-QAM for FBMC-QAM, an M-PAM consteation for the FBMC-OQAM system, and strict equaity for δ t δ f in Tabe 1, the spectra efficiency, as N grows arge, in both cases becomes FBMC = og 2 (M)R c b/s/hz. (4) Thus, compared with OFDM the oss due to the CP and spectra guard bands has vanished. Regarding spectra efficiency for SCM, instead, the idea choice for p(t) is a sinc puse with doube sided bandwidth W = 1/T s Hz. However, in practice this is not possibe, so a smoother puse in frequency is used. Let the bandwidth of p(t) be W tot = (1 + δ)w = (1 + δ)/t s, where δ measures the excess bandwidth in comparison to the sinc puse. Then, the spectra efficiency becomes ρ SC = R cζ g og 2 (M) (1 + δ) b/s/hz, where ζ g = (2G + 1 G cp )/(2G + 1) is the inefficiency due to the cycic prefix. Finay, regarding TFS, in a muticarrier system ike FBMC, the two parameters δ t and δ f contro the amount of compression of time and frequency, respectivey. In the specia case of δ t = δ f = 1, the subcarrier spacing, in the case of a puse shape with no ro-off, is exacty the reciproca of the symbo time T s, which means that the time-frequency occupancy per compex input symbo d k, becomes exacty 1 Hz-s which is the smaest possibe occupancy if an orthogona set of puses is desired. For TFS-QAM with time and frequency packing activated, i.e., δ t δ f < 1, an M-QAM consteation, and a rate R c code, the spectra efficiency becomes ρ TFS QAM = R c og 2 (M) δ t δ f b/s/hz. (5) For TFS-OQAM with an M-PAM consteation, the spectra efficiency becomes ρ TFS OQAM = R c og 2 (M) 2δ t δ f b/s/hz. (6) Thus, a spectra efficiency gain proportiona to 1/δ t δ f is achieved compared with an FBMC system, at the cost of increased interference among the symbos {d k, }. Note that, by setting the imit vaues of δ t δ f in the two equations (δ t δ f = 1 and δ t δ f = 0.5 respectivey), (5) and (6) coapse into (4). In sma ces, where the SNR can be very high, the current trend is to empoy high-order consteations, such as 256-QAM or 1024-QAM. This is in sharp contrast to TFS, which maintains a sma consteation size, such as quaternary PSK (QPSK) or 16-QAM, but increases the degree of time-frequency compression in order to achieve higher spectra efficiencies.

4 DISCUSSION AND LITERATURE OVERVIEW As aready commented, OFDM is a muticarrier moduation format wherein the use of a CP and a proper spacing among subcarriers ensure orthogonaity of the waveforms moduated by different data symbos. In genera, the amount of interference among adjacent (both in time and frequency) data symbos is rued by the samping on the time-frequency pane of the ambiguity function associated to the prototype puse shape p(t), expressed by [8, 7, 9] A p (τ, ν) = p(t)p (t τ)e j2πνt dt. (7) t Thus, in order to minimize the interference from adjacent symbos in time (intersymbo interference, ISI), and in frequency (interchanne interference, ICI), severa research efforts have been dedicated to designing puse shapes with good ambiguity functions, i.e., according to an orthogona design in both the domains, as expressed by A p (δ t T, kδ f /T ) = δ[k]δ[], where δ[i] is the Kronecker deta function. An exceent overview in this respect is provided in [9]. However, doube orthogona designs exist ony when δ t δ f > 1. Furthermore, mutipath channes coud destroy orthogonaity, and mismatched fitering may be preferabe in this case [8]. Anyway, aso with mismatched fitering, doube-domain orthogonaity can be granted (with some SNR penaty in AWGN) ony when [9, 8] δ t δ f > 1. For instance, OFDM preserves orthogonaity in frequency-seective (muti-path) channes by adding a guard time between successive symbos, by means of a CP or zero padding (ZP) [25, 26] which eads to δ t δ f = 1 + T cp /T > 1. Furthermore, constraining the symbos to be rea (or imaginary), i.e., using PAMs rather than QAMs, orthogonaity can be granted aso when δ t δ f = 1/2, as aready noticed in the first studies about muticarrier systems, [27, 28], and successivey caed Offset-QAM-based OFDM (OFDM- OQAM) [29], which reaizes a rectanguar attice staggering in the time-frequency pane. Regarding OFDM, orthogonaity is ost in the presence of frequency synchronization errors or phase noise, which cause non negigibe performance oss to OFDM(A) systems [30, 31, 32, 3]. Furthermore, orthogonaity is aso ost (and performance significanty degrades) if any carrier frequency offset (CFO) is present [30] or the mutipath channe is significanty time-varying (douby-seective) within the symbo period T s. In this case, interference canceation/mitigation techniques shoud be considered aso for the orthogonay designed OFDM systems [33, 34, 35, 36]. This fact is one of the main motivations for recent research efforts on fiterbank muticarrier (FBMC) schemes that, expoiting simiar approaches to combat ISI and ICI, by proper puse shape designs may combat the sensitivity to CFO and douby-seective channes, sti preserving spectra efficiency with δ t δ f = 1 [37]. Actuay, the same phiosophy can be used aso when δ t δ f < 1 [17], e.g., with the generaization of FBMC according to an FTN principe [13, 15, 16, 18]. The idea is that reaxing the orthogonaity constraints [38], the puse shape design has higher degrees of freedom to reduce ISI and ICI sensitiveness under douby-seective channes or CFO effects. Turning back to the issue of spectra efficiency maximization, we note that ideay a sinc puse shoud be used in singe carrier FTN. In practice a smoother spectrum with ro-off δ is instead empoyed. In an AWGN channe and without TFS, the adoption of these puses woud resut in a oss of a factor 1/(1 + δ) from the Shannon imit in terms of spectra efficiency. However, it can be proved that with FTN the maximum overa spectra efficiency, even when δ > 0, tends to the Shannon imit. Hence, with FTN the excess bandwidth is not imposing any oss at high SNR [39]. Unfortunatey, the impressive rate gains of singe carrier TFS do not in genera carry over to FBMC systems. The reason is that with FBMC, the excess bandwidth is typicay smaer and imited to the ast subcarriers at the band edge. Yet, there are reasons that motivate why TFS may sti be attractive in muticarrier systems, which we discuss next. First, one of the constraints in the design of a cassica FBMC system is that the time and frequency transated puses shoud form an orthonorma basis so that the data symbos can be demoduated independenty in an AWGN channe. However, in a channes, save for the specia case of an AWGN channe, orthogonaity of the puses is anyway ost at the receiver. This requires some form of an equaizer structure at the receiver side, and such equaizer can just as we be designed so that it aso equaizes the sef-induced interference. Sti, the constraint of orthogonaity puts heavy restrictions on the FBMC design and, by reaxing it, additiona degrees of freedom in the puse design are made avaiabe at the cost of a controed amount of interference. In cases where the aocated bandwidth to one user is sma, the amount of excess bandwidth at the band edge can sti be reativey arge. In such cases, TFS can beneficiay expoit the side obes to increase the spectra efficiency. Take the LTE system as an iustrative exampe: in LTE s 1.4 MHz downink mode, ony 1.08 MHz of the band is used for transmission. The remaining 0.32 MHz is a guard band, and does not contribute to the data rate. With TFS, the guard band starts contributing to the data rate, giving an improved spectra efficiency. Lasty, TFS offers a fexibe method to adapt the spectra efficiency through varying the two compression parameters δ t and δ f. With FBMC, the data rate can ony be adapted in discrete steps by changing the consteation size and the coding rate. With TFS, a much finer granuarity is achieved. As an extra bonus, TFS may aso reduce the number of error correcting codes as it can maintain the same code rate but adapt the spectra efficiency by controing the parameters δ t and δ f. Moreover, TFS creates a shaping effect of the input consteation, so that an SNR gain is typicay achieved over

5 standard QAM-type consteations. DISCRETE-TIME MODEL In what foows we outine a discrete-time mode for the considered moduations, which can be obtained by samping the genera waveform in (2); moreover, we give an expression for the discrete-time received signa after it has passed through a (possiby) time varying channe with impuse response h c (t, τ). Thus, by empoying a samping frequency F c = 1/T c = N s T s, with N s an integer representing the oversamping factor, the discrete-time signa s [n] = s (nt c ) associated to the -th symbo is expressed by N 1 1 s [n] = N k=0 N 1 = p[n] N k=0 d k, p[n]e j2πk δ f δ t Tc n Ts }{{} p k [n] d k, e j2πk δ f δ t Tc Ts n } {{ } d [n] where p[n] = p(nt c ) is the discrete-time puse shape during the time support [0, (Q 1)T c ]. Note that, when δ f δ t 1, this corresponds to transmitting phase-rotated symbos (differenty for each subcarrier and symbo period), as expressed by d k, = d k, e j2πδ f δ tk. The first equaity in (8) highights that the signa is obtained by mutipexing the data by a bank of fiters p k [n], whie the second shows that the signa is aso a time-domain windowing p[n], independent of, of a muticarrier (OFDM-ike) signa d [n]. Coecting the transmitted sampes in a Q 1 vector s = [s (0),..., s (nt c ),..., s ((Q 1) T c )] T the two equaities suggest equivaent bock-matrix representations, as expressed by s = N 1 d k, p tk = [ ] p t0,..., p tk,..., p tn 1 d k=0 }{{} = [ P t F H Q pf0,..., p fk,..., p fn 1] d }{{} (9) = P f ] diag (p t0 ) [ f 0,..., f k,..., f N 1 d } {{ } F H where d ] represents the N 1 transmitted data with [ d = d k,, p tk is the Q 1 k-th discrete-time puse shape with [p tk ] n = p k [n], F Q is a Q Q unitary DFT matrix with [F] k+1,n+1 = 1 Q e j 2π Q kn, p fk = F Q p tk represents the k-th puse shape in the discrete frequency-domain, [ F] and F is a N Q pseudo-dft matrix with =, k+1,n+1 1 N e j2πδ f δ Tc t Ts kn, whose row-vectors f k H represent the moduation frequencies. Note that, the signa vector s is obtained k (8) by a prototype puse-shaping fiter p(t) that spans Q/N s consecutive bocks, which are transmitted every T s = N s T c seconds. Thus, each symbo woud generate ISI to the adjacent ones, uness it is designed according to an orthogona paradigm, e.g., by a Nyquist principe. Observing (8), and that a time-domain mutipication induces a circuar convoution in the DFT domain, if the signa parameters are chosen such that the DFT frequency bins are aigned with the moduation frequencies, i.e., if Q = 1 δ f δ t MN s Q, M, N s, N the matrix F H is obtained coecting the equi-spaced (by M) rows of the Q Q IDFT matrix F H Q. We define Z n (Z n ) as the Toepitz matrix with a zeroes, but ones in the n-th sub-diagona (super-diagona). The transmitted vector during the -th symbo period is thus expressed as x = m Z mns s +m = m Z mns F H Q P f d+m. (10) Denoting, as aready specified, by h c (t, τ) the (possiby) time-varying channe, h (c) i,j = h c (it c, jt c ) is the discretetime counterpart, and H (t) c, the Q Q channe matrix that processes [ the ] signa transmitted at the -th symbo period, with H (t) c, = h (c) N s+i,i j. In order to recover the i+1,j+1 data d transmitted with the -th data-bock, it is necessary to observe the channe output for (at east) QT c seconds, and the associated received vector is expressed by y = H (t) c, x + w = m H m, d +m + w = H (t) tot, d(ong) + w, (11) [ where d (ong) =..., d T 1, d T, d ] T T +1,... is the vector containing both the data of interest and the interference, and w represents the noise at the receiver. In the ight of the muticarrier moduation format, the observation mode can aso be convenienty expressed in the frequency domain by projecting y on the same DFT grid of size Q, obtaining y (f) = F Q y = H (f) = H (f) c m totd (ong) + F Q w C m P f d +m + w (f) (12) where H (f) tot = F Q H (t) tot is the tota observation matrix in the frequency domain, H (f) c = F Q H (t) c F H Q is the frequencydomain channe matrix, C m = F Q Z mn F H Q is a fu (diagonay dominant) matrix that modifies the puse shaping matrix P f (note that C 0 = I Q ), and we omit in the foowing the dependence on of the channe matrices for notation compactness.

6 It is worth noting that the observation modes in (11)- (12) share high simiarities with the equaization of OFDM signas in douby-seective channes, and severa inear and non-inear data receiver structures may be borrowed, possiby incuding (data-aided) ISI and ICI canceation [34, 35, 36, 10], as we as joint iterative (turbo) equaization and decoding, [33, 40]. Here for simpicity, we assume separate data equaization from decoding, and we ony consider inear approaches such as matched-fitering (MF), east squares (LS), and inear MMSE. Focusing on the frequency-domain observation mode, the (soft) estimates of the transmitted data is generay expressed by ˆd = diag (ɛ ) Gy (f), where [ɛ ] k = e j2πδtδ f k compensates the phase-rotation when δ t δ f 1, G contains the centra rows of the fu equaization matrices G MF = H (f) H tot, GLS = H (f) tot, or ) 1 G MMSE = H (f) H tot H (f) toth (f) toth + σ 2 n I Q [41]. Extensions to other moduation formats and discussion. As anticipated in the system mode section, the data vector may contain some signa processing of the rea information vector a, which in the inear case, can be captured by a precoding matrix, e.g., d = Θa, and the equaization/detection strategy modified accordingy. A sort of precoding Θ p on non-finite aphabets, actuay a prefitering, may be aso appied to each vector s. This way, by proper definition of the pre-fitering/pre-coding matrices Θ p, Θ, aso Generaized- FDM (GFDM) [42], as we as Universa-FDM (UFDM) [43], can be casted in this framework. Note that, cassica FBMC in (8)-(9) performs a pre-fitering in the time domain by a diagona matrix, and consequenty a circuar precoding on the data d. However, a different structure can be imposed to the pre-fitering matrix, such as to be fu in the time-domain and bock-diagona in the frequency domain, jointy performing spectrum shaping on a bock of subcarriers, rather than separatey on each one, as proposed for UFDM in the ongoing research project 5GNow [43], and somehow reminescent of sub-bocks precoding in [25]. Adaptation to muti-antenna systems is aso straightforward by coecting data and observation vectors at each antenna, eading to an observation matrix whose size increases proportionay to the number of antennas. Obviousy, the overa compexity, as we as the amount of (inter-antenna) interference wi increase, making more chaenging the use of MIMO and STC (Aamouti) systems, which heaviy rey on the orthogonaity (e.g., absence of ISI/ICI) offered by OFDM in frequency-seective channes. This has probaby been one of the strongest objections for empoyment of FBMC-ike systems so far. However, severa researchers have aready proposed agorithms to dea with these probems, within the great effort of the PHYDIAS project [44] to estabish and promote FBMC-based wireess communications (see [45, 8] and references therein). Generay, observing that aso OFDM faces amost the same probem in douby-seective channes, where it suffers ony ICI, channe estimation agorithms, receiver structures, and overa system design can take inspiration by the abundant iterature on this subject [46, 47]. For instance, receiver time-domain windowing is effective in this sense to boost the signa-to-noise pus interference ratio (SINR), as proposed in [33, 35] for pure OFDM. Actuay, transmitter and receiver time-domain windowing have been jointy optimized in [48] in muticarrier communications without CP. Recenty, maximum SINR approaches for MIMO-FBMC have been investigated in [49, 50], showing negigibe performance degradation with respect to OFDM and significant performance gain with respect to the first attempts to MIMO-FBMC [44, 8]. PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT The moduation formats here discussed wi now be compared when used in a typica ceuar environment. In particuar, we considered the Extended Typica Urban (ETU) channe defined in [51]. This is an exampe of time- and frequencyseective channe whose continuous-time impuse response can be modeed as h c (t, τ) = k c k (t)δ(τ τ k ) (13) where fading coefficients c k (t) and continuous-time deays τ k are typica of each anayzed scenario, and δ(τ) is the Dirac deta. From the mode (13), the foowing discrete-time mode has been adopted h (c) i,j = k c k,i δ[j j k ] where coefficients c k,i have been generated according to [52], and the discrete-time deays j k have been chosen as an approximation of continuous-time deays in (13) to their cosest integer-mutipe of T c. As mentioned, a key figure of merit is represented by the ASE. Indeed, by propery taioring the channe code to the considered moduation and the actua channe characteristics, the ASE performance can be cosey approached. On the contrary, a comparison based on the bit or packet error rate (PER) performance for a given code does not resut to be fair since the code must be specificay taiored to the considered moduation format. Generay speaking, and assuming a quasi-static channe, a code designed for the additive white Gaussian noise channe is expected to work we jointy with OFDM or FBMC with offset (or other orthogona signaing formats). On the contrary, this kind of code wi exhibit a significant performance degradation when used with moduation formats which expicity introduce ISI and/or ICI, as TFS or FBMC without offset. By considering the above mentioned channe we are aso, impicity, assessing the robustness of the considered moduation schemes against mutipath.

7 We wi assume perfect channe state information at the receiver. Thus, our anaysis does not take into account the degradation due to an imperfect channe estimation and the different osses, in terms of spectra efficiency, due to possibe different requirements in terms of training or piot sequences inserted for an accurate channe estimation. The ASE resuts wi be reported as a function of the ratio between the signa power P and the noise power P n computed on a reference bandwidth of 1.92 MHz. The spectra of the considered puses p(t) are reported in Fig. 1. In the figure, we see the sinc puse adopted by OFDM, a puse with RRC spectrum and excess of bandwidth of 10% (fiter ength Q = 1280, M = 10) adopted for FBMC-OQAM and singe carrier moduations, and the puse proposed in the PHYDIAS project [53] for FBMC (fiter ength Q = 640, M = 5), where its improved frequency seectivity has been accompished by using a onger and spectray we-shaped prototype fiter. In a cases, for OFDM, we wi set the osses due to the cycic prefix and to the insertion of a number of guard tones compiant with the LTE standard, i.e., 16% in terms of ASE. Moreover, the transmitted symbos, for a the waveforms, wi be affected by a random error vector magnitude (EVM) of 4%, with the aim of modeing various imperfections in the impementation (such as carrier eakage, phase noise, etc.). The fractiona MMSE equaizer G MMSE is adopted at the receiver for a schemes with the exception of FBMC-OQAM, for which we used a matched fiter foowed by an MMSE equaizer. Indeed, the required ength of the fiter, for orthoghonaity in FBMC-OQAM, makes the receiver compexity too high to use a fractiona MMSE. Figs. 2 and 3 show the ASE performance for the two extreme scenarios of very ow- and high-mobiity, characterized by Dopper frequencies f d = 0 and f d = 30kHz on the ETU channe. We consider QAM with high cardinaity M = 64. The figures compare OFDM with FBMC, when N = 128 carriers are spaced by 15 khz. For comparison, we aso show the ASE curve of a singe carrier with CP system with the same bandwidth 1.92 MHz. We see that, for the ow-mobiity case, OFDM, FBMC-QAM and FBMC-OQAM have simiar performance: FBMC-OQAM achieves a higher spectra efficiency w.r.t. other moduations for ow and medium P/P n, but at high P/P n vaues it is outperformed since it has a imited compexity receiver. Instead, performance of SCM is quite imited, since its waveform is strongy affected by the frequency seectivity of the channe, and ASE is imited by the CP oss. In case of high-mobiity, we see that FBMC-OQAM performance coapses, since its orthogonaity is competey destroyed. Instead, FBMC-QAM is more resistant to Dopper and it aso gains w.r.t. OFDM. Since high-order consteations are more sensitive to the impact of the interference present when non-orthogona signaing is adopted, we aso studied the same scenario when the moduation has cardinaity M = 4. We can see from Fig. 4 that, for this scenario, FBMC outperforms a other moduation formats. We aso point out that for a the considered channes, FBMC gains can be even higher by means of a propery designed puse [9, 17]. We now consider the same scenario when TFS is adopted. Fig. 5 shows the performance of TFS when M = 4. Different spacing vaues δ t and δ f have been considered and, to have a wider insight on the possibe benefits of this technique, we report the highest ASE achievabe when packing in the time domain ony (δ t = 0.90), in the frequency domain ony (δ f = 0.95), and in both domains (δ t = 0.90 and δ f = 0.95) is adopted. We can see that TFS gains with respect to FBMC are imited, and ony at high P/P n. This is, in some way, expected: further gains coud be obtained with more compex receivers (techniques of advanced treis processing [13, 54]) but, on the other hand, it coud be difficut to find substantia gains, since FBMC is aready a sort of time-frequency packing. Our own feeing is that these are first resuts and more research on this topic is required. As aready discussed, the ASE can be approached in practice with proper moduation and coding formats. Fig. 6 shows the BER of OFDM and FBMC-QAM for the scenario of Fig. 3. The adopted codes are ow-density parity-check codes with rate 1/2 and bockength 64,800 bits. In a cases, a maximum of 50 decoder iterations were performed. We can notice that performance is in accordance with the ASE resuts. We point out that the oss from the theoretica imit is twofod: first, the adopted code has finite ength. Second, it is not designed for the considered channe: the use of codes propery designed for this kind of channes can consideraby reduce the oss. Summarizing, as aready anticipated in the introduction, we are far away to estabish which shoud be the preferred system, because resuts highy depend on the specific scenario. Thus, extensive work sti has to be done in order to identify optima design strategies, which incude setting the optima right number of carriers (possiby different for different signa waveforms, especiay in the presence or the absence of CP), the optima puse-shaper design, which may strongy depend on the information avaiabe at the transmitter about the channe maximum deay spread, maximum Dopper spread, and ampitude statistics, and the optima ength of the CP, as suggested for exampe in [55], wherein an OFDM system with tunabe ength of the cycic prefix is proposed. SINGLE CARRIER FTN MULTI-USER MODULATION WITH MASSIVE MIMO 5G Macro base stations wi certainy be equipped with arge scae antenna arrays, a technoogy aso known as massive MIMO [56, 57]. Using a arge number of antennas wi hep to boost the network throughput, since accurate beamforming wi permit serving severa users in the same ce and on the same bandwidth, and to stabiize the propagation channe

8 by reducing channe outages by virtue of diversity. The joint design of interference coordination schemes and moduation formats for massive MIMO systems is a topic that wi certainy gain momentum in the coming years. Let us discuss the upink between U singe antenna users and a base station equipped with N BS antennas. The impuse response, assumed time-invariant for simpicity, between the u-th user and the n-th base station antenna is denoted by h u,n (t), and we assume these to be perfecty known at the base station side. Each user transmits a, CP-free, singe carrier FTN signa according to P Ts x u (t) = d u, p(t T s ). N BS The array gain is here harvested as a power saving at the user side and not as increased signa strength at the base station side. The received signa at the n-th antenna becomes U P Ts y n (t) = d u, z u,n (t T s ) + n(t), N BS u=1 where z u,n (t) is the received puse from the u-th user at the n-th antenna, i.e., z u,n (t) = p(t) h u,n (t), where denotes convoution. To keep compexity ow, we consider ony singe-user detection and construct a discrete-time sequence y u = {y u, } for the detection of user u according to N BS y u, = y n (t) zu,n( t). t=ts n=1 In the case of no FTN, the receiver mode is y u, = γ u d u, + η u, where γ u is a measure of signa strength for the u-th user and η u, coects noise, intersymbo interference, and interuser interference. Under the assumptions that a channe impuse responses are independent and that rich scattering is present, the effect of etting N BS grow is that the impact of intersymbo and interuser interference becomes ess and ess; asymptoticay they both vanish. In such favorabe propagation environments, there is no need for any muticarrier system to mitigate muti-path as one-tap equaizers can be used, and severa users can be spatiay mutipexed, which increases spectra efficiency. Whie a singe carrier system has ower PAPR compared with FBMC systems, there is a reduction of spectra efficiency since puses with excess bandwidth of an amount δ must be used. To reduce the oss of the excess bandwidth, we make use of FTN. Aso in this case it hods that ICI vanishes as N BS grows, but it is no onger true that ISI vanishes. Therefore, we must mode the sequence y u as y u = g u d u + η u, where g u is the effective impuse response for user u and η u coects interuser interference and noise for user u. A sequence detector is now needed in order to equaize the channe g u. Performance resuts with ive massive MIMO channe measurements. We next report resuts for singe carrier moduation in measured massive MIMO channes. Severa channe measurement campaigns on massive MIMO has been conducted at Lund University, and more information about the particuar one we make use of here can be found in [58]. In brief, 4 users were paced outdoors around the EE-buiding at Lund University separated by roughy 30 meters, and a inear 128 eement antenna array was paced at the roof of the buiding. The users were paced without any ine-of-sight to the base station. The measurement bandwidth is 50 MHz and severa snapshots of the propagation channe were taken. In Fig. 7 we report resuts for the no FTN case, i.e., δ t = 1. The puse p(t) is RRC-shaped with 20% excess bandwidth. We report averaged ASE vaues over the four users for the system described previousy for 4-QAM and 16-QAM, using 16 or 128 antenna eements. The curves marked with AWGN show the resuts obtained when we artificiay remove a intersymbo and interuser interference and therefore constitute upper bounds. As can be seen, there is a cear gain in going from N BS = 16 to N BS = 128, and for 4-QAM, the gap to the upper bound is cosed. With 16-QAM, the intersymbo and interuser interference has not fuy vanished, which shows up as a oss compared with the upper bound. To see how strong the interuser interference is, we aso test the case of a singe user, i.e., U = 1. In this case, the gap to the bound reduces, but is not fuy cosed. This means that the intersymbo interference is stronger than what the singe-tap equaizer used can hande. Moreover, the ASE vaues can be boosted by switching to FTN transmission. In Fig. 8 we repeat the experiments from Fig. 7, but we use compex Gaussian moduation symbos and activate FTN; in a cases we use N BS = 128 and U = 4. In this test we assume an equaizer that can optimay dea with the intersymbo interference, but treats the interuser interference as noise. As a benchmark system, we show the ASE for the impractica but optima sinc puse. As we can see, there is a oss in ASE by using the RRC puse with δ = 0.2. By using FTN, part of this oss is overcome as the ASE curve moves coser to the curve for the sinc puse. Atogether, we have demonstrated that with massive MIMO, much of the intersymbo and interuser interference can vanish, so that a singe-tap equaizer works we for singe carrier moduation systems. With FTN activated, the oss of the excess bandwidth is reduced. With more advanced transceiver schemes, for exampe based on interference canceation, the gap to the upper bounds in Fig. 7 can be reduced, and taken together with the favorabe PAPR of singe carrier, this moduation format seems to be a good choice for upinks of 5G whenever arge antenna arrays can be faciitated. Athough we presented here resuts for the singe carrier ony, it is reasonabe to foresee that a simiar behavior can be observed aso for muticarrier moduation formats, such as FBMC and OFDM: in fact in a massive MIMO system when

9 the number of receiving antennas is sufficienty high, the interuser and intersymbo interference introduced by the channe tend to vanish, no matter the moduation adopted. Such a property has been caed sef-equaization and reported aso in [59]. INTERACTIONS WITH 5G ARCHITECTURE AND RE- QUIREMENTS In this section we finay discuss the interactions between the reviewed moduation formats and some key requirements and features of 5G networks. Indeed, athough a compete description of how a 5G ceuar system wi ook ike is not yet avaiabe, some pieces of the puzzes are aready known and amost unanimousy taken for granted [55]. Some of the concepts discussed here are aso summarized in Tabe 2. Large data rates 5G networks wi have to support very arge data rates; such a goa wi be accompished through a combination of technoogies such as the use of mutipe antennas (as aready discussed), the use of adaptive moduation schemes and of course the use of arger bandwidths. This fact tends to promote the use of a muticarrier moduation for two reasons: (a) adaptive moduation is easiy impemented with muticarrier schemes, wherein smart bit oading agorithms may permit to tune the moduation cardinaity and the coding rate according to the channe status on each subcarrier; and (b) the use of arger bandwidths eads to increased mutipath distortion, thus impying that using a muticarrier scheme simpifies the task of equaization with respect to a singe carrier moduation. Sma ces and mm-wave communications The use of sma ces is a key technique aimed at increasing the overa capacity of wireess networks, intended as offered throughput per square km; recenty, there has aso been a growing interest for mm-wave communications [60, 61] for supporting short-range ceuar communications. Athough there is sti itte knowedge about mm-wave propagation in urban areas, studies are ongoing [62]. It is anticipated that mm-wave wi be used on short distances, thus impying that ine-ofsight inks might be avaiabe. In this case, we wi have arge bandwidths, rather stabe propagation environments, and ow Dopper offsets. The design of a moduation scheme suited for these conditions is sti an open probem, athough again muticarrier schemes appear to be much more suited than singe-carrier schemes. Due to their anticipated stabe propagation environments and ow Dopper eves, sma ce networks may be especiay suitabe appication areas for non-orthogona moduation formats. For FBMC, channe estimation gets inherenty more chaenging due to the interference at the receiver side. However, with increased stabiity of the propagation environment and ow Doppers, this burden gets significanty simpified. The same arguments aso appy to, e.g., advanced FBMC equaizers that equaize the interference among the symbos. Such equaizers need to be updated frequenty in the case of non-negigibe Dopper eves, which may impose hefty compexity increases compared with OFDM where ony a singe tap per detected symbo needs to be updated. On the other hand, there is aso a ine of thought that foresees, for these high frequencies and arge bandwidths, the use of simpe moduations formats with ow spectra efficiencies, deferring to future generations of ceuar systems the task of optimizing the spectrum usage in these bands. The recent paper [63], instead, proposes the use of a singe-carrier moduation with cicic prefix as a remedy to the PAPR probem of muticarrier schemes. Uncoordinated access - internet of things In the coming years there wi be a tremendous increase in the number of connected devices [64, 65]. Indeed, the current trend is to incude a wireess transceiver in amost every eectronic gadget/equipment, and researchers have been investigating for some years the so-caed internet of things This is aso caed Machine-to-Machine (M2M) communications. A arge number of connected devices wi require to access the network to transmit short messages. The chaenge posed by the internet of things ies, rather than in a capacity shortage, in the overwheming burden that it produces on the signaing functions of the network. Regarding this aspect, the use of FBMC moduations is preferabe with respect to cassica OFDM since it aows uncoordinated (i.e. asynchronous) access to the subcarriers. This is one of the main messages conveyed by the ongoing 5GNOW european research project. Low atency Another requirement for 5G wireess ceuar systems is the possibiity to ensure ow atency communications with a target roundtrip deay of 1ms. This is seen as a major change of 5G network with respect to existing LTE networks, since it wi enabe the so-caed tactie Internet [66], which wi permit the deveopment of brand new rea-time appications for monitoring and contro. To reduce atency at the physica ayer, a singe-carrier moduation seems to be preferabe, since it avoids bock-processing of the data which introduces additiona deays. A tunabe OFDM system, with an adaptive choice of the ength of the data bock woud aso be an option. Energy efficiency It is expected that 5G ceuar networks wi be far more energy-efficient than previous ceuar systems [67]. Energy saving is mainy a matter that regards higher-ayer of the network protoco stack, since it invoves adaptive base station switch on/off agorithms, use of renewabe energy sources, design of energy-harvesting protocos, base station sharing among network operators during off-peak hours, etc. However, at the physica ayer, adaptivey switching off unused carriers is a key strategy that may be used to

10 save energy from the RF transceiver chain of base stations. This thus once again promotes the use of muticarrier systems with respect to singe-carrier moduation. Coud techniques and software radio Another fascinating feature of future wireess networks is the possibiity of having a coud-based radio access network [68, 69]. In practice, base stations wi be substituted by ight devices, performing baseband-to-rf conversion and signa transmission, and connected through wired optica inks to a data center, wherein data coding/decoding and higher-ayer functionaities such as resource aocation wi take pace. The advantages of this structure are represented by the fact that centraized/cooperative strategies (such as the we-known coordinated mutipoint) can be readiy impemented, as we as by the fact that data moduation can be impemented by a software running in a data center. This adds a ot of fexibiity to the choice of the moduation format, in the sense that paves the way to adaptive moduation schemes wherein not ony the cardinaity and the coding rate may be tuned, but even the waveform itsef, incuding the cycic prefix; the recent 5G overview [55] thus proposes the use of tunabe OFDM, a sort of adaptive scheme with parameters chosen based on the instantaneous operating conditions. Thus, according to the channe conditions, to the requested throughput, and to the avaiabe resources in terms, e.g., of number of antennas, adaptive schemes may be designed wherein the moduation format itsef is a parameter to be optimized. We beieve that, of a the key characteristics of 5G networks, the integration of coud and software defined networking strategies within the 5G architecture wi be the one to have the greatest impact on the definition of the future moduation format. CONCLUSIONS This paper has provided a review of some inear moduation schemes aternative to OFDM and deemed as suitabe candidates for the impementation of the air interface of future 5G ceuar communications. A comparison of these moduation schemes in terms of ASE in a ceuar environment has been carried out. Our resuts have shown that there are aternatives to OFDM offering increased vaues of spectra efficiency, as we as that there is no definite winner, in the sense that the preferabe moduation format depends on the considered scenario in terms of channe Dopper spread, channe deay spread, and some other parameters, such as, e.g., the aowed receiver compexity. In this sense, the virtuaization of the air interface and the impementation of a coud radio access network may pave the way towards the adoption of a tunabe, adaptive moduation, wherein waveform parameters are chosen based on the specific considered scenario. The paper has aso reported some discussion on the use of TFS in massive MIMO systems, and has presented a discussion on how the moduation format impacts and is impacted by key technoogies and requirements of future 5G networks. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors woud ike to thank Professor Fredrik Tufvesson and his research group for providing the massive MIMO channe measurements. REFERENCES [1] A. Ghosh, J. Zhang, J. G. Andrews, and R. Muhamed, Fundamentas of LTE, Pearson Education, [2] H. Ochiai and H. Imai, On the distribution of the peak-toaverage power ratio in OFDM signas, IEEE Trans. Commun., vo. 49, no. 2, pp , Feb [3] M. Morei, Timing and frequency synchronization for the upink of an OFDMA system, IEEE Trans. Commun., vo. 52, no. 2, pp , Feb [4] T. Hwang, C. Yang, G. Wu, S. Li, and G. Ye Li, OFDM and its wireess appications: a survey, IEEE Trans. Veh. Tech., vo. 58, no. 4, pp , May [5] R. Irmer, H. Droste, P. Marsch, M. Grieger, G. Fettweis, S. Brueck, H.-P. Mayer, L. Thiee, and V. Jungnicke, Coordinated mutipoint: Concepts, performance, and fied tria resuts, IEEE Commun. Mag., vo. 49, no. 2, pp , Feb [6] S. Haykin, Cognitive radio: Brain-empowered wireess communications, IEEE J. Seect. Areas Commun., vo. 23, no. 2, pp , Feb [7] G. Matz, H. Bocskei, and F. Hawatsch, Time-frequency foundations of communications: Concepts and toos, IEEE Signa Processing Mag., vo. 30, no. 6, pp , Nov [8] B. Farhang-Boroujeny, OFDM versus fiter bank muticarrier, IEEE Signa Processing Mag., vo. 28, no. 3, pp , May [9] A. Şahin, I. Güvenç, and H. Arsan, A survey on prototype fiter design for fiter bank based muticarrier communications, IEEE Communications Surveys & Tutorias, Dec [10] G. Matz and F. Hawatsch, Fundamentas of time-varying communication channes, F. Hawatsch and G. Matz, Eds., Academic Press, [11] G. Wunder, M. Kasparick, S. ten Brink, F. Schaich, T. Wid, I. Gaspar, E. Ohmer, S. Krone, N. Michaiow, A. Navarro, et a., 5GNOW: Chaenging the LTE design paradigms of orthogonaity and synchronicity, in Proc. Vehicuar Tech. Conf., Dresden, Germany, June [12] T. Fusco, A. Petrea, and M. Tanda, Sensitivity of mutiuser fiter-bank muticarrier systems to synchronization errors, in Proc. IEEE Internationa Symposium on Communications, Contro and Signa Processing, St. Juian s, Mata, Mar. 2008, pp [13] J. E. Mazo, Faster-than-Nyquist signaing, Be System Tech. J., vo. 54, pp , Oct