Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 1 of 23 PageID #: APPENDIX C

Transcription

1 Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 1 of 23 PageID #: APPENDIX C

2 Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 2 of 23 PageID #: Appendix C: Category 1 s Who Object to Settlement Amounts Last First Bates Begin Bates End BRAITHWAITE SHERMAN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X BRESILIEN HENRY MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Peter Gleason X MARIN HECTOR MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ MARTIN KHALID MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X RODRIGUEZ ARNALDO MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Peter Gleason X VELEZ RAYMOND MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X* X ROMERO ROLANDO MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Peter Gleason X SONERA CARLOS MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X * established good cause for his untimely objection.

3 Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 3 of 23 PageID #: Appendix C: Category 2 s Who Object to Their Individual Back Pay Awards Based on Allocation Methodology Last First Bates Begin Bates End ALPHONSE ROBERT MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X BARCENE MICHAEL MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ BATSON WAYLAND MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ BERRIOS EDWARDO MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ BRAITHWAITE SHERMAN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X BUCHELLI BORIS MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ DANIELS AARON MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X DAVIS SHARIF MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ DE LA CRUZ EDUARDO MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ DETRES RAYNARDEE MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X GARRIDO RICHARD MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X HILL DWAYNE MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Levy Ratner X HOLLINGSWORTH LAWRENCE MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X HOWELL ERROL MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ HUTCHINSON DAREN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X IGBOWU NATHANAEL MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X KIMBROUGH LOUIS MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X LAURENCEAU HAROLD MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X LAURENCEAU JERRY MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Levy Ratner X X LEGER ALEX MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X MACIAS JAVIER MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ MARIN HECTOR MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ MARTIN KHALID MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X FORBES TENISHA MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X MENENDEZ DAVID MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X MERCADO ORLANDO MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ MYERS ANTHONY MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X X NAVARRO EDDYS MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ PARKER HARRY MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ POUERIET RAFAEL MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ RIVERA WALTER MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Page 1 of 3

4 Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 4 of 23 PageID #: Appendix C: Category 2 s Who Object to Their Individual Back Pay Awards Based on Allocation Methodology Last First Bates Begin Bates End RODRIGUEZ ANTHONY MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ RODRIGUEZ JOHN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ ROLDAN ERIC MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X X SANTANGELO MICHAEL MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Margaret Santangelo X SIERRA LUIS MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X SINGLETON JOSEPH MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ STEWART DONALD MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ TALTON JASON MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X TANIS JEAN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X UCETA FRANKLIN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X VARGAS JOSEPH MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X VEGA CARLOS MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ VELEZ RAYMOND MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X* X ADAMS JASON MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X BETANCOURT DAVID MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Jose Pena & Associates/ Sandford Rubenstein X BRANFORD HASANI MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X CHILE LUIS MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X COUCH DARRELL MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ CRONENBERG CHRISTOPHER MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X DIAZ ROBERT MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X DUARTE MAURICE MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X FIGUEROA ROBERT MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X FOSTER SEAN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X LOPEZ THOMAS MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X MARTINEZ JACKIE-MICHELLE MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X PAYNE CHRISTOPHER MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X PETERS OMAR MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X X Page 2 of 3

5 Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 5 of 23 PageID #: Appendix C: Category 2 s Who Object to Their Individual Back Pay Awards Based on Allocation Methodology Last First Bates Begin Bates End QUINONES MATTHEW MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Wellerstein Associates ROBERTS SEAN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X SCOTT IHSAN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X THOMAS ABUNDI MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X VIRRUSO PIETRO MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X WAITE DAMION MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X CUMINALE CARL MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ FERNANDEZ JASON MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ MIRANDA JEFFREY MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X PRIDGEON TERRENCE MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X X * established good cause for his untimely objection. Page 3 of 3

6 Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 6 of 23 PageID #: Appendix C: Category 2-a s Who Object That Their Back Pay Awards Do Not Equal What They Would Have Earned as Firefighters Last First Bates Begin Bates End ALPHONSE ROBERT MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X BARCENE MICHAEL MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ BERRIOS EDWARDO MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ BRAITHWAITE SHERMAN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X BUCHELLI BORIS MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ DANIELS AARON MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X DAVIS SHARIF MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ DE LA CRUZ EDUARDO MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ DETRES RAYNARDEE MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X GARRIDO RICHARD MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X HILL DWAYNE MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Levy Ratner X HOWELL ERROL MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ HUTCHINSON DAREN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X IGBOWU NATHANAEL MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X LAURENCEAU HAROLD MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X LAURENCEAU JERRY MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Levy Ratner X X LEGER ALEX MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X MARIN HECTOR MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ MARTIN KHALID MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X FORBES TENISHA MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X MENENDEZ DAVID MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X MERCADO ORLANDO MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ MYERS ANTHONY MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X X NAVARRO EDDYS MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ PARKER HARRY MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ POUERIET RAFAEL MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ RODRIGUEZ JOHN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ ROLDAN ERIC MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X X SANTANGELO MICHAEL MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Margaret Santangelo X SIERRA LUIS MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X Page 1 of 3

7 Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 7 of 23 PageID #: Appendix C: Category 2-a s Who Object That Their Back Pay Awards Do Not Equal What They Would Have Earned as Firefighters Last First Bates Begin Bates End SINGLETON JOSEPH MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ TALTON JASON MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X TANIS JEAN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X UCETA FRANKLIN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X VARGAS JOSEPH MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X VEGA CARLOS MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ ADAMS JASON MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X BETANCOURT DAVID MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Jose Pena & Associates/ Sandford Rubenstein X BRANFORD HASANI MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X CHILE LUIS MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X COUCH DARRELL MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ CRONENBERG CHRISTOPHER MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X DIAZ ROBERT MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X DUARTE MAURICE MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X FIGUEROA ROBERT MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X FOSTER SEAN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X LOPEZ THOMAS MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X MARTINEZ JACKIE-MICHELLE MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X PAYNE CHRISTOPHER MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X PETERS OMAR MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X X QUINONES MATTHEW MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Wellerstein Associates X ROBERTS SEAN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X SCOTT IHSAN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X THOMAS ABUNDI MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X VIRRUSO PIETRO MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X WAITE DAMION MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X CUMINALE CARL MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ FERNANDEZ JASON MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Page 2 of 3

8 Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 8 of 23 PageID #: Appendix C: Category 2-a s Who Object That Their Back Pay Awards Do Not Equal What They Would Have Earned as Firefighters Last First Bates Begin Bates End MIRANDA JEFFREY MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X * established good cause for his untimely objection. Page 3 of 3

9 Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 9 of 23 PageID #: Appendix C: Category 2-b Nonhire s Who Object to Use of Interim Earnings to Calculate Their Back Pay Awards Last First Bates Begin Bates End BATSON WAYLAND MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ HILL DWAYNE MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Levy Ratner X KIMBROUGH LOUIS MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X MARIN HECTOR MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ RIVERA WALTER MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ RODRIGUEZ ANTHONY MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ STEWART DONALD MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ VELEZ RAYMOND MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X* X * established good cause for his untimely objection.

10 Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 10 of 23 PageID #: Appendix C: Category 2-c Delayed-Hire s Who Object That Their Back Pay Awards Do Not Equal the Difference Between Their Interim Earnings and What They Would Have Earned as Firefighters Last First Bates Begin Bates End DE LA CRUZ EDUARDO MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ HOLLINGSWORTH LAWRENCE MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X FORBES TENISHA MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X ADAMS JASON MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X PRIDGEON TERRENCE MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X * established good cause for his untimely objection.

11 Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 11 of 23 PageID #: Appendix C: Category 2-d Who Objects That Priority Hires Should Receive Greater Back Pay Awards Than Nonhire s Not Appointed to the FDNY Last First Bates Begin Bates End MACIAS JAVIER MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ * established good cause for his untimely objection.

12 Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 12 of 23 PageID #: Appendix C: Category 3 s Who Object to the Calculation of Their Individual Awards Last First Bates Begin Bates End BRATHWAITE DONALD MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X CASTRO RUBEN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ CHAMBERS RICARDO MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ CRUZ DANIEL MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X DALEY ANITA MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X DARBY DEVIN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X HOLDER RIVOLENA MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X LIBURD ELLERY MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ MOLINA AARON MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ SANTANGELO MICHAEL MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Margaret Santangelo X CRONENBERG CHRISTOPHER MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X DELLAVALLE GREGORY MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X GOMEZ DAVID MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X * established good cause for his untimely objection.

13 Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 13 of 23 PageID #: Appendix C: Category 3-a Nonhire s Who Object That Their Back Pay Awards Were Calculated Assuming Maximum Average Interim Earnings Last First Bates Begin Bates End BRATHWAITE DONALD MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X CASTRO RUBEN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ CRUZ DANIEL MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X DALEY ANITA MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X HOLDER RIVOLENA MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X * established good cause for his untimely objection.

14 Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 14 of 23 PageID #: Appendix C: Category 3-b Who Objects to Damages Category Used to Calculate Award Last First Bates Begin Bates End CHAMBERS RICARDO MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ * established good cause for his untimely objection.

15 Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 15 of 23 PageID #: Appendix C: Category 3-c Who Objects to Award and Requests to Withdraw Claim for Relief Last First Bates Begin Bates End GOMEZ DAVID MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X * established good cause for his untimely objection.

16 Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 16 of 23 PageID #: Appendix C: Category 3-d Nonhire s Who Object That Their Interim Earnings Should Have Been Discounted When Calculating Their Back Pay Awards Last First Bates Begin Bates End MOLINA AARON MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ SANTANGELO MICHAEL MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Margaret Santangelo X * established good cause for his untimely objection.

17 Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 17 of 23 PageID #: Appendix C: Category 3-e Delayed-Hire s Who Object That Months of Delay Used to Calculate Their Back Pay Awards Are Incorrect Last First Bates Begin Bates End CRONENBERG CHRISTOPHER MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X DELLAVALLE GREGORY MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X * established good cause for his untimely objection.

18 Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 18 of 23 PageID #: Appendix C: Category 3-f s Who Object That They Were Not Awarded Additional Fringe Benefits Last First Bates Begin Bates End DARBY DEVIN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X LIBURD ELLERY MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ MOLINA AARON MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ * established good cause for his untimely objection.

19 Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 19 of 23 PageID #: Appendix C: Category 4 s Who Object to Employee Pension Contributions Being Withheld from Their Back Pay Awards Last First Bates Begin Bates End HILL DWAYNE MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Levy Ratner X WHYTE LAURIETTE MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X * established good cause for his untimely objection.

20 Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 20 of 23 PageID #: Appendix C: Category 5 s Who Object to Issues Outside the Scope of the Decree Last First Bates Begin Bates End ASSEMIAN FELIX MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X AVILA JOSE MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ BRAITHWAITE SHERMAN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X HERMO ANTHONY MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X HILL DWAYNE MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Levy Ratner X MERCADO ORLANDO MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ NAVARRO EDDYS MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ PATRICK ANTOINE MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Levy Ratner X SANTANGELO MICHAEL MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Margaret Santangelo X STEWART DONALD MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ WHYTE LAURIETTE MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X VARGAS JOSEPH MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X YAR MOHAMED MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ CRAWFORD MALIK MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ FOSTER SEAN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X PAYNE CHRISTOPHER MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X QUINONES MATTHEW MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Wellerstein Associates X * established good cause for his untimely objection.

21 Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 21 of 23 PageID #: Appendix C: Category 6 s Who ted Blank or Unknown Objections Last First Bates Begin Bates End CABRERA DAMIAN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Mr. Coiro X GARCIA JOSE MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X GILLIS DERECK MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ MICHEL GLINORY MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X WILLIAMSON DAMEL MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Levy Ratner X X GORIS ERVING MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X ROMAN RICARDO MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X * established good cause for his untimely objection.

22 Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 22 of 23 PageID #: Appendix C: Category 7 s Who Returned Submissions That Were Supportive of Decree or Non-Objections Last First Bates Begin Bates End DE COSTA EMMETT MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ GARCIA DANIELLE MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X HEARD CORRY MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X X DUTCHIN SIMONE MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ * established good cause for his untimely objection.

23 Case 1:07-cv NGG-RLM Document Filed 09/22/14 Page 23 of 23 PageID #: Appendix C: Category 8 s Who ted Objections Last First Bates Begin Bates End HEARD CORRY MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X X LAURENCEAU JERRY MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ Levy Ratner X X MARTIN KHALID MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X MYERS ANTHONY MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X X TANIS JEAN MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X VELEZ RAYMOND MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X* X PETERS OMAR MRCD-OBJ MRCD-OBJ X X * established good cause for his untimely objection.