English Literature. Shakespearean Genres Unit A2 1 Othello ENGLISH LITERATURE. Content/Specification Section

Transcription

1 Shakespearean Genres Unit A2 1 Othello English Literature Content/Specification Section Page Starting Point 2 AO1 Plot, Characters, Themes 4 AO2 Dramatic Methods 11 AO3 Contexts 13 AO4 Connections 15 AO5 Argument and interpretation 16

2 Starting Point In this unit there are 5 Assessment Objectives involved AO1, AO2, AO3, AO4 and AO5. AO1: Textual knowledge and understanding, and communication In this examination, the candidate should be able to articulate informed and relevant responses that communicate effectively knowledge and understanding of the selected play. This Assessment Objective (AO) involves the student s knowledge and understanding of the play, and ability to express relevant ideas accurately and coherently, using appropriate terminology and concepts. Quality of written communication is taken into consideration in all units. AO2: Dramatic methods In this examination, the candidate should analyse Shakespeare s use of such dramatic methods as characterisation, structure, language and staging. The student should analyse relevantly the ways in which meanings are shaped in plays. This means identifying dramatic features and showing how these features relate to the key terms of the question. Discussing dramatic methods advice to teachers and students: In this component, equal marks are available for the candidate s treatment of the extract and other relevant parts of the text. As the unit is closed book, examiners will be realistic about the amount of detail from the wider text which can be provided in the time available. Every play has its memorable phrases which come to mind when writing, but it is anticipated that the larger-scale features of form, structure, language and staging will be helpful in constructing a relevant response. The student will, however, be expected to respond in a more detailed fashion to the use of language and dramatic methods within the given extract. A reminder of the process of identification (of methods), illustration, analysis, and relation to the question may be timely. AO3: Contexts In this examination, the candidate should demonstrate understanding of the significance and influence of the contexts in which a play is written and received by drawing on appropriate information from outside the play. Each question will specify a particular type of context in the stimulus statement/ directive. In this unit the stipulated context will be literary and will focus on the nature of a particular Shakespearean genre. Contextual information offered should be of this stipulated type. It should be relevant to the question. And it should be external to the play itself. pg 2

3 Contextual information which is made relevant to the key terms of the question will be rewarded. Students should be aware that little credit can be given for contextual information that is introduced merely for its own sake. They should remember that the text has primacy over the context. A good response will use contextual information sparingly and judiciously. AO4: Connections In this examination, the candidate should explore connections within a Shakespeare play, and between the extract accompanying the question and the wider text. The student should explore similarities and differences between characters, plot lines, themes, staging, and other dramatic techniques within the play and its wider context. Significant, pointed connections which are made relevant to the key terms of the question will be rewarded. AO5: Argument and interpretation In this examination, the candidate should offer opinion or judgment in response to the given reading of the play, taking account of the key terms as the basis of the argument. This AO is the driver of Unit A2 1 and is of primary importance. AO5 can be satisfied in full by the candidate developing his/her own reading in response to the given reading. If, however, critics are used, they must be used with understanding incorporated into the argument to reinforce or be seen as an alternative to the student s opinion not used as a substitute for the development of the student s own opinion properly acknowledged. Coherence and relevance of argument will be rewarded. Students should be aware of the importance of planning in the sequencing and illustration of the reading they wish to put forward. They should also beware of the danger of replacing the key terms of the question with others of their own choosing which they assume mean much the same thing. The following information is neither prescriptive nor exhaustive, but is intended as a starting point for teachers and students. It reflects some of the stylistic and contextual issues which may be explored and developed further both in the classroom and through teachers and students own independent research. pg 3

4 AO1: Plot, Characters, Themes Genre: Tragedy Themes are indicated where key words are emboldened. The themes apply not just to the topic being discussed in the indicated area, but across the whole play. Summary One of Shakespeare s tragedies, Othello is recognised as unique in its intimacy of domestic setting, widely applicable themes and arguable equal accountability for the downfall of the eponymous character. Central characters Iago and Othello, are akin in allowing their unfounded emotions to determine their actions. Both wear the mantle of responsibility for the tragic tale Iago s villainous machinations, and Othello s weakening of strength, mutually interweave to propel the plot to its ultimate conclusion. Protagonist and antagonist are central to the outcome, making a viewing of the play both moving and painful, inciting both fear and pity in the audience. With no subplots, and little humour to lighten the ominous mood, the audience can only watch as Othello swiftly descends into paranoia, becoming emotionally distraught, and desiring an exacting revenge on the innocent Desdemona. Iago s lack of reasoning for his hatred based loosely on a rumour is powerful in its determination to wreck and ruin, harnessing Roderigo as a pawn, and exploiting Cassio s every innocuous move single-mindedly motived to exact a consequence of tragic proportions. Plot Summary Act One, evening time, on a street in Venice, rejected suitor Roderigo and recently appointed ensign Iago meet and plot revenge against the latter s superior, the Moor of Venice, General Othello. Insulted by his limited promotion by Othello, Iago protests friendship for Roderigo and promises to exact a penalty from the General, new husband to Desdemona rejecter of Roderigo s love. Iago begins with incensing Desdemona s father, Brabantio, against Othello awakening him in the night and angering him with news of his daughter s elopement. Secreting his presence, Iago removes himself to inform Othello of Brabantio s imminent arrival, the warning interrupted by the arrival of Othello s Lieutenant, Michael Cassio. Complying with the verbal command of the Duke of Venice, Othello takes himself to the Duke and other senators who inform them of their military need for him. Brabantio arrives with accusations that Othello is permitted to rebuke, with the called for presence and testimony of Desdemona supporting the honesty of their devotion. Othello being commanded to Cyprus, leaves immediately; Iago, his wife Emilia and Desdemona to follow behind. Iago encourages Roderigo to gather his fortune and follow them to Cyprus. Upon arrival, in Act Two, as they wait for the safe arrival of Othello and his pg 4

5 crew, Iago spies his opportunity of inciting distrust between Othello and Desdemona, by exploiting the innocent friendship of the new bride with Cassio. Encouraging Roderigo to believe in the truth of an affair between the latter, Iago manipulates a situation whereby Cassio and Roderigo fight damaging the Lieutenant s reputation and causing Othello to dismiss his beloved Cassio from his service. In Act Three, Desdemona intends to assist Cassio with his desire to be reinstated, but upon the arrival of Othello to this meeting, Cassio removes himself a situation manipulated by Iago in suggesting guilt in the actions of the innocent pair. Iago casts further seeds of doubt in Othello s mind, forcing his imagined infidelity to come to life. Continuing to press upon the weakened mind of the General, Iago uses a conversation between himself and Cassio overheard by Othello whereby the words spoken confirm Othello s worst fears. Supported by the presence of Desdemona s handkerchief a present from Othello, and given to Iago by his wife appearing in the wrong hands, Othello is unwaveringly convinced of his wife s betrayal and commits himself, in Act Four, to exacting a brutal revenge. When an envoy arrives seeking the return of Othello to Venice and the placing of Cassio in his stead, Desdemona s pleasure at the news incites rage from Othello and he strikes his wife. Iago sees the opportunity to remove Cassio and/or Roderigo from the scene, in Act Five, convincing Roderigo to attack Cassio. Cassio is stabbed by both Roderigo and Iago. Iago ends Roderigo s life, and when Othello hears the cries he mistakenly believes Cassio has been killed, in completion of a promise made to him by Iago. Having sent Desdemona to wait for him in their bedchamber earlier, Othello, in the final scenes, will not hear the protestations of his wife as she begs to understand his actions. Othello suffocates his wife, justifying himself to Emilia when she enters, in detailing his reasons for believing Desdemona unfaithful. Emilia, too late, is able to explain as false the vows made by Iago. Upon hearing her utter his guilt, Iago kills his wife and attempts to escape. He is arrested and some of his machinations are uncovered offstage in discussion with the survivor Cassio, and reading of letters found on the body of Roderigo. Othello offers himself up for arrest, detailing how he wishes to be remembered, before stabbing himself with a concealed weapon and kissing his wife as he dies. It is promised that Iago will be tortured for his role in the tragedy that has unfolded. Characters Othello Like the reed that will break rather than bend, Othello is a character whose greatest strengths become vulnerabilities in weakness. Trust and loyalty two traits which encompass the personage of Othello are the making and the failing of the man. When the implicitly trusted Iago sheds doubt on the loyalty of Desdemona, Othello cannot open himself to a hinted or questioned possibility. Instead the words and proofs offered by Iago become the new truth. He does not doubt Iago s loyalty and so in turn allows the trust he had in, and united loyalty he felt with, his wife to be shattered. What was balanced and orderly in Othello s mind has been exploded, he has succumbed to Iago s machinations. Honesty and deception are inverted. Chaos reigns. We may question why Desdemona is not allowed to defend herself why Iago s loyalty is trusted before Desdemona can prove her own the answers vary the relative longevity of Iago and Othello s relationship, the fear of always remaining the outsider, to restore her good name, the need to restore order to society, etc. The need to question, and the lack of resolution is what ensures the tragedy remains tragic. pg 5

6 Before we are even introduced to the person of Othello, his character is being lambasted by his ensign, Iago. Iago declares the man as loving his own pride and purposes (I.1.12) above all else; and Othello and Desdemona s marriage is defamed in vile terms, reduced to an account of elopement, thievery and bestiality. Never has a character s traits and circumstances been so destroyed in a Shakespearean play, before the audience has a chance to meet with the person in question, and it is the most evident use of foreshadowing that Othello s character shall continue to be manipulated and misused for the purposes of another. When Othello does appear, his loyalty to the state and their reciprocate need for him is made evident. As a general and commander of Venetian armed forces, Othello is a lauded warrior. That being said, his length of time in service and military skill proven in his ability to remain alive and successfully so, from the age of seven has made him an outsider from the world of civility, little of this great world can I speak More than pertains to feats and broils of battle. (I ) He is also an outsider in the societal world of Venice. He is extolled by the highest echelons of Venetian society and government but he is not, and never will be, one of them. His welcome is conditional evidenced quite clearly in the outrage of Desdemona s father Brabantio whose admittance of Othello into his family home loved me, [and] oft invited me (I.3.27) has been sorely overreached in the marital union. Nature and society are now in err (I.3.62) societal conditions have been breached. Othello is a Moor with all the awe and horror that this word implied to his peers in Venice. When Desdemona became enthralled, she had eyes and chose me (III.3.193), Othello felt no hint of the outcast. But it is upon a doubt in her choice, and that eventually she should prefer her own clime, complexion and degree (III.3.235) that Othello s confidence is shaken and he becomes once more different from the rest. It is the mutual love found with Desdemona that has quieted whatever inadequacies Othello has felt, whether from the years of service or the need to belong, and the words I do love thee, and when I love thee not, /Chaos is come again. (III ) are more painfully prophetic every time they are heard. Othello is not easily roused to jealousy casting off Iago s insinuations of guilt in Desdemona being attractive and attracting attention in return. I ll see before I doubt; when I doubt, prove; And on the proof, there is no more but this: Away at once with love or jealousy. (III ) Once the seed is planted however, and the proofs unfold, Othello has succumbed. The ferocity at which Othello falls into the hands of Iago has long ignited the critic. When bemoaning his part in Desdemona s death, Othello refers to himself as not having loved wisely is it the choice of beloved, or actions he now decries? Others have highlighted Othello s guilt of self-idealization where Desdemona s betrayal is linked to her husband s love of reputation My name, that was as fresh/as Dian s own visage, is now begrimed and black/as mine own face. (III ). A final comment highlights the need to question Othello s inherent savagery. Once bent on exacting a punishment, Othello promises murderous actions, nothing less will do. A monster is unleashed. Was he everpresent? And how does this reading of Othello reflect on our own thoughts of him now? pg 6

7 Iago Iago is an experienced and capable soldier, husband of Emilia, widely respected and friend of many. When the play begins, he has been named ensign to General Othello a slight he feels most keenly, believing he has been looked over for a more deserving post. With that as an initial motivator, it is Iago who poisons the mind of Othello, manipulates the actions of Roderigo and traps the innocent Cassio in a scheme laid purely for his own revenge. As he attempts to maintain the control he has claimed, and direct the chaos he has created, Iago s scheme reaches a conclusion that ensures the destruction of Othello and Desdemona as well his own wife Emilia and Roderigo. What Iago makes of this ending, we will never know, promising, From this time forth I never will speak word. (V.2.310). There is no repentance, no seeking of redemption, nor no gloating nor jubilation. In Iago s words What you know, you know, (V.2.309) we may know some, but we understand little. And so the tragic potential for evil continues, uncontained and uncontainable. Motivated but seemingly motiveless, it is Iago s lack of convincing reason for his hatred of Othello that makes him an image of evil itself. A much more complex version of the stock Vice character of Medieval morality plays, Iago is connected with the role of Devil in Religious morality plays. Referred to as a devil on several occasions (albeit only towards the end, when more is revealed), it is Iago s own words that align him with God s antithesis. Line 65 of the opening scene has Iago pronounce I am not what I am (I.1.65) an inversion of God s statement to Moses in Exodus (Ex.3.14) I am that I am. Iago s outward appearance belies what writhes within, his evil wears an honest face. Iago is a consummate villain. What are Iago s claimed motives? How convincing are they? Consider what Samuel T. Coleridge referred to as motiveless malignity. Iago is in turns brilliant, horrifying and enthralling to observe. With a baseless hatred Iago lays schemes at will, mastering his own arts of manipulation and the luck of fate as he makes his way into Othello s mind. It is only to Roderigo that Iago admits his desire to hurt Othello in some way, I follow him to serve my turn upon him (I.1.42), but it soon becomes obvious that Roderigo is not a bosom companion of Iago, but yet another relationship of opportunity, that proves Iago s inability to feel affection for anyone. Has he always been this way? On different occasions, Iago is named as being honest, reliable, a straight talker, a beloved companion. Has Iago s reputation been another manipulated creation, serving his own purposes all along? Find both positive and negative references to Iago spoken throughout the play. Iago s choice of behaviour represents all that is repulsive in man s soul. His intelligence and cunning are terrifying. He is a master manipulator, bent on achieving his own will. He understands the mind of his fellow man more than most, and choses to warp the strengths in others, into becoming their weaknesses. What is continually horrifying about Iago is his ability to comfortably belong in all corners of humanity, being a capable and successful member of society, while all along masking his true desires. Desdemona Desdemona is a youthful character who can be seen at times as bold and determined, alongside submissive and faithful. Her personality traits are exploded and expounded by different characters as the play unfolds. Iago initially casts Desdemona in the role of sexually enjoyed victim of Othello, an idea contradicted by her father who exclaims and praises her role as subservient and faithful daughter. As it transpires, the union between Othello and Desdemona was one of choice, albeit made independently of her pg 7

8 father. Brabantio is heartbroken and dies from grief within the time scale of the play. For Iago however, the accusations of being inappropriately sexually active, are exactly what he delights in hanging further gossip upon. Desdemona becomes an innocent lamb sacrificed in the raging fury of Othello s pain, with the complicit involvement of Iago. When the play opens, Desdemona, once faithful and submissive daughter to Brabantio, Senator of Venice, has newly become a faithful and submissive wife to Othello, Moor of Venice. My noble father, You are the lord of duty, I am hitherto your daughter. But here s my husband, And so much duty I challenge that I may profess Due to the Moor my lord. (I ) A member of the upper levels of Venetian society, Desdemona has forsaken the rules of her house and society in choosing, independently, to elope with an outsider of opposing colour, class and kin. With a greedy ear (I.3.148) Desdemona devoured the stories of Othello s history, in his words She loved me for the dangers I had passed (I.3.166). Desdemona is strong willed and honest in her speech; her attachment to Othello is sincere, if idealised. Desirous of following him in his campaigns, she with capability takes on the expected role of General s wife, acting as host and befriending Othello s subordinates. She believes herself of being allowed an audience of his ear, and a part of his decisions. Whether such an ideal relationship could have flourished, we shall never know, as Iago takes it upon himself to ensure the destruction of the marriage as inevitable. Desdemona is an innocent character, frequently painted as the Christ-like good to Iago s demonic evil. To continue the comparison, Desdemona is betrayed by those she loves, and whom should love her in return. She falls for an older, fascinating and experienced man who feels he has reached a long-awaited contentment in finding reciprocated love with her. For Desdemona however, the journey is only beginning and she looks forward to many tomorrows. Othello ends such hopes. Iago, is placed as protector of Desdemona as her husband carries out his military role. Iago makes use of Desdemona as a pawn twisting and corrupting every innocent move and choice of language. Once again she is betrayed. Roderigo is a rejected suitor of Desdemona but one who cannot accept the refusal. His desire for her continues to flourish and ensures an involvement in a plot which ends her life. Once more, a desire for Desdemona leads to her destruction. Once a beloved daughter, Brabantio cannot accept nature would err in allowing Desdemona to desire Othello. I ll not have it so (I.3.234) he declares when she may require accommodation upon Othello s departure. Rejected by familial blood, her wedded partner, sworn protector and desirous suitor, Desdemona is impotent to the end. Her hands are tied. Various readings have been made of Desdemona s final scenes. Does she fight and resist with grit as she boldly declared of the strike received from Othello s hand I have not deserved this (IV.1.240) or willingly submit to Othello s fury, incapable of understanding or refuting the rage he feels for her. Modern readings often read a resistance into Desdemona s actions is this necessary? If we continue to associate Desdemona with Christ we see a love freely given, and a love that does not die in death. The last selfless words expressed by Desdemona, confirm this undying love even further. pg 8

9 Emilia: Desdemona: O, who hath done this deed? Nobody, I myself. Farewell. Commend me to my kind lord. O, farewell! (V ) Roderigo Roderigo is a gentleman of Venice, and a rejected suitor of Desdemona who retains intense feelings for the lady so much so he is capable of being manipulated into plots by Iago, with the false promise that Roderigo s assistance will draw Desdemona ever closer to himself. Roderigo s character degrades as the plot unfolds, and where there are occasions when we feel a measure of sympathy for him both as a victim of Iago, and in his doomed love his gullibility and willingness to participate in the cruel and violent schemes laid out by Iago allow fate to attend upon him, and he learns of his victimhood too late. Cassio Cassio is a handsome, rich and widely respected soldier, newly appointed to Lieutenant by Othello. His looks, charm and inability to drink without incident I have very poor and unhappy brains for drinking (II ) are manipulated as weaknesses by Iago. Iago belittles the new honour placed upon Cassio by reducing him to a great arithmetician (I.1.19) lacking in Iago s self-proclaimed battle-hardened experience, a jealousy born of resentment from Cassio s class privileges promoting him over the head of Iago. Iago further discredits Cassio in ensuring the Lieutenant loses his good reputation and standing with Othello. This cuts Cassio deeply, and his need to regain his position is a circumstance easily manipulated by Iago. Devoted to Othello and untempted by his wife, Desdemona, despite Iago s insinuations, Cassio is the only character used by Iago who escapes with his life. Emilia Emilia is both a loyal wife to Iago, and loyal lady s maid to her mistress Desdemona. Emilia s character grows as the play unfolds, demonstrating a strong-willed, more mature and sharply critical personality. How Iago s devious behaviours have never been recognised by the savvy Emilia, previous to this occasion are questionable, but her shock in the final scenes demonstrated in the repeated My husband? reveal a genuine disbelief that he could be the mastermind behind Othello s misinformation, and Desdemona s death. If this ignorance is true Emilia s deliverance of the handkerchief is a moment of unwitting complicity in the tragedy of her mistress, where her loyalty and devotion to Iago goes unquestioned, because she has no reason to do so. She wishes to please her husband, I nothing, but to please his fantasy (III.3.303) which further explains her lack of curiosity in Iago s desires for the handkerchief love token. She thought less of the relationship of Othello and Desdemona, than of her own a reasonable situation. Emilia is not from the little interaction we are privy to a silent acceptor of Iago s abuse, refuting his occasional insults with a defiant You ha little cause to say so (II.2.111). Emilia is not ignorant of questionable behaviour in the world, accurately suspecting and naming Othello s tormentor as some eternal villain (IV.2.134). In Act Four, Emilia reveals more understanding in the discussion of fidelity and marital betrayal with Desdemona than her mistress possesses. Experience has taught her that men and women are more than equal in their passions and desires something Desdemona is yet to discover. It is this perceptive understanding of the sexes that ensure Emilia will not be physically or verbally intimidated by Othello, nor by Iago. Her determination to be heard, to defend her innocent mistress, and her honest description of both men in the concluding scene make Emilia someone to be admired. She does not shirk from responsibility when discovering her complicity in Othello s deceptions nor does she hold [her] peace (V.2.225) as bid by pg 9

10 her husband, despite his intimation of violence. Her dying words take comfort in her own honesty, So come my soul to bliss as I speak true (V.2.257). pg 10

11 AO2: Dramatic Methods Staging The Shakespearean stage was sparse. Locations were named and imagined, not lavishly depicted; tempests were decried and thus experienced; players declared themselves invisible, and so they were; disguises were impenetrable. On the Elizabethan stage, the audience s belief was not suspended, their belief was instructed. Stage entrances and exits lend an assistive role with Iago s machinations his convenient removal before Brabantio appears downstage in the first scene, for example, allows him to have stirred the nest but not be identified. When entering upon a scene, Iago is quick to manipulate what he finds there consider his and Othello s arrival upon the conversation between Desdemona and Cassio in Act Three, scene One. Movement around the stage lend a natural fluidity to the experience of a play, and in moments of dramatic necessity, positions are taken that allow for the concealment of a character. Being hidden is of symbolic import, in permitting a scene to unfold, a proof to be heard, or a plot to develop. Othello eavesdrops on Cassio Stand you a while apart (IV.1.73) Iago instructs him, so the Moor will interpret Iago s conversation with Cassio Quite in the wrong (IV.1.102). Hiding has not allowed Othello to uncover a truth, but rather to misinterpret even more the dramatic irony is significant. Iago conceals himself at the opening of Act Five, with a false promise to Roderigo, as he states he will be Here at thy hand (V.1.7) to assist. Combined with a number of exits and re-entries, Iago s movement in the scene act as a symbol for his machinations throughout promising falsely, appearing and assisting to advance himself alone, and taking the opportunity to remove any who would identify his actions. The use of the marriage bed in the final scenes of the play are a particularly effective staging tool. The bed allows for stage-like imagery in Desdemona s death: the symbolic innocence of such a location, the indication of corruption of the marriage and the location of the confused Desdemona placed in the metaphorical and literal centre of the plot. The opening and closing of the curtains are equally dramatic in the concealment and slow revelation of what has occurred. The curtains conceal the actions of Othello, keep secret from Emilia the death of her mistress, and once thrown wide, reveal the extent of the crime to the audience and players alike. Imagery Throughout Othello, Shakespeare s choice of figurative language propels several significant themes and ideas. The imagery of black and white, light and darkness, heaven and hell are all significant in establishing concepts of race, knowledge, virtue and vice. Many of the actions in Othello occur in the dark of evening, or late at night. Shadows conceal truths, and the sun does not have opportunity to reveal the treachery. When pg 11

12 Desdemona begs Othello, Kill me tomorrow; let me live tonight (V.2.87) her desperation is one born from the hope that daylight will sweep away the metaphorical darkness of the night. The plea is too late. The disparaging and insulting words associated with Othello s difference of skin colour all fall from the tongues of our villains Iago, Roderigo and Brabantio. Black ram sooty bosom and repeated reference of the word black are as a negative. The Senate sees only a valiant Moor (I.3.47), Desdemona saw the true face and inner soul of Othello, in my mind (I.3.252), and Emilia is more interested in the black heart of the villain who is persecuting Othello, than the blackness of skin before her. If any racism does exist in Othello, it takes the form of insult, jealousy and anger action not recommended to the audience. Othello is not capable of maintaining his fairness however and too soon internalises the negativity placed at his door. At the heart of Othello is a paradox based on the traditional interpretations of white and black, light and darkness. It is the black Othello who is far more fairer than black (I.3.291), and the white Iago who revels in hellish schemes of treachery. It is Iago who spreads darkness into the mind of Othello, ensuring Othello s misled desire to Put out the light (V.2.7). Desdemona fair paper (IV.2.73) and heaven-sent has been mislabelled and recoloured by Iago s words. Othello longs to wipe clean the apparent stain of Desdemona s blackening sins, and prevent them from happening again her image is now begrimed and black to Othello s mind. Maintained virtue has become suggested vice, the heaven of their unity has become a burning hell (V.2.138) and the light of Desdemona s love has become obscured in Othello s darkening vision. Props Handkerchiefs were significant in early modern Europe. They represented wealth and status, and the possession of another s handkerchief spoke volumes of the implied relationship. Othello gifted Desdemona with an embroidered handkerchief as a love token, one which Desdemona kept by her To kiss and talk to (III.3.300). Othello imbues the token with significance, allowing it to manifest into an ominous symbol of loyalty and fidelity and ironically it is for Emilia, when considering her giving it to Iago. The handkerchief moves from hand to hand following this instance, misused and misappropriated, becoming instead a symbol of destructive power, far from its original exchange between lovers. Critics often pin the moment of sealed tragedy on the actions of Emilia. Consider however the scene where Othello rejects the offered handkerchief when Desdemona attempts to ease his headache. Othello disregards it with Your napkin is too little (III.3.291) and it is he who drops it. The significance of this moment should not be overlooked. Othello has both metaphorically and literally rejected Desdemona s love and plays his part in the selffulfilling tragedy of their love. pg 12

13 AO3: Contexts The form of a Classic Greek Tragedy as articulated by Aristotle is one into which Othello can fit. A word of caution here, however do not push too hard Shakespeare s variants on tragedy are just as interesting. Inevitable doom is at the heart of Aristotelian tragedy and from the outset, Iago has said doom planned for Othello. The hero of the classic tragedy is usually one of high status, royalty or fame. A domestic tragedy also popular during the Renaissance contains a less socially impressive protagonist, being of middle or lower class status. It has been argued that Othello himself could fit into either, possibly more ordinary than the typical high-ranking hero. That being said, the respect given to Othello by the noblemen of Venice, and his own claims of descending from men of royal siege (I.3.22) are enough to elevate his status. Our hero is a tragic one a hero in possession of a trait which is simultaneously something that makes him great, as well as being the flaw that becomes his downfall. Hubris being over ambitious and prideful is the typical tragic flaw. We could argue Othello into this corner, but the painfully ironic flaw of trust and loyalty are just as convincing. Next comes hamartia an error in judgement which seals the tragic fate of the hero. Othello s listening to Iago would be such an error unless we consider the error to have been within Othello all along. Does Iago poison Othello s mind too easily? Fate also intervenes. The tragic hero is thus beset by both inner and outer forces who combine to effect his downfall. There are opportunities for redemption, and it is the lack of recognition of these moments that make the fall all the more tragic. In the conclusion of Greek tragedies, a catharsis is experienced. The once ordered society has been temporarily thrown into chaos the conclusion is the moment when the fog clears and the resettling occurs. The audience and players purge their emotions, and we allow for a return to normality at the conclusion of the action. The sincerity of Othello s repentance and the continued presence of Iago in Othello, however, have often been called into question when contemplating the latter scenario. Some semblance of order is restored, in that several acts of evil have reached their dramatic end, but it isn t comfort we feel at the end of Othello. In fact, a continued discomfort at the very real possibility of similar scenarios reoccurring, is more likely felt. Justice is not fully served because to do so would too unconvincingly conclude such a convincing tale. If pity and fear are to be our key emotions in a Greek tragedy, then as the curtains close on Othello, there is ample opportunity for both. Where our sympathy lies however is an interesting question traditionally the hero is looked at with pity, but it is no difficult leap to suggest the majority look to Desdemona with tears, instead of her husband. Jacobean Revenge Tragedy and Senecan Tragedy may also have influenced Shakespeare lending a taste of the more bloodthirsty and less restrained to the plot. The graphic I ll tear her all to pieces! (III.3.436) is a brutal image, more suited to a violent villain than pg 13

14 a flawed hero. For Aristotle, however, the tragic hero needs not be categorised as purely good or consummately evil. The interworking of the two is the more interesting, and more convincing. pg 14

15 AO4: Connections Students should be keenly aware that there are equal marks available for their treatment of the extract and the wider text in the exam. The focus should be on parallels or connections between the extract and the wider text which are relevant to the key terms of the stimulus statement. It may be beneficial for students to prioritise connections that also reveal their knowledge and understanding of the dramatic methods (AO2) and the nature of Shakespearean Tragedy (AO3). When studying the play, you will note many connections and it may be useful to track elements which show parallels or contrasts. pg 15

16 AO5: Argument and interpretation Question Throughout the tragedy as a whole, Iago has no motive for the evil he does. By referring closely to Extract 1 and to other appropriately selected parts of the text, show to what extent you would agree with the view expressed above. Your argument should include relevant comments on Shakespeare s dramatic methods, and relevant external contextual information on the nature of Shakespearean Tragedy. N.B. Equal marks are available for your treatment of the given extract and other relevant parts of the text. AO1 Consider What has led to the exchange printed in the extract? Consider Iago s intentions and the reason for Roderigo s capitulation. Iago speaks the words of most consequence in the extract and yet leaves Roderigo to bear the burden of responsibility consider the slander Iago is inciting, and the way he oversteps the words of Roderigo. Look to the conversation exchanged immediately before the extract Iago outlines his feelings for Othello, and his intentions of abusing the relationship. Look to the words of Iago in reply to Brabantio s Thou art a villain! (not included in the extract) Iago s plain speaking and knowledge of himself as villain make for a character who does not hide his motivation there is no deeper reasoning behind Iago s actions what he feels, is what he speaks to the audience at least. Iago s later passing comment of Emilia and Othello s possible connection he does not linger on it for doing so may prove how insubstantial it is and yet this is a cause for his actions. Iago s easy manipulation of any situation the enjoyment he takes from making the innocuous, poisonous. Iago s easy manipulation of any character until his wife is able to see his actions and breaks the bond between them. AO2 Staging Iago and Roderigo both speak but only Roderigo identifies himself and Iago exits as soon as Brabantio makes to come downstairs. The movement and position of Cassio and Desdemona, at various stages of the play is manipulated by Iago. The positioning of Othello, hidden from sight, when Iago speaks to Cassio later in the play, is manipulated to Iago s advantage. The hidden involvement of Iago in staged fights between Cassio and Roderigo, are manipulated to Iago s advantage repositioning himself when he sees moments of opportunity. pg 16

17 Imagery Iago s choice of words poisons the minds of those around him consider the imagery created in the words chosen to describe Othello and Desdemona s relationship in the extract. Consider how he speaks of Othello in his asides to the audience throughout the play. Consider how he abuses the idea of honesty when speaking to Othello about Cassio throughout the play. Consider how he encourages Othello to consider himself an outsider both of society, and from Desdemona s love, throughout the play. Props Emilia knows not why Iago would want Desdemona s handkerchief, and yet he asks for it a hundred times. Iago manipulates the transport of the prop into Cassio s hand, and thus Bianca s hand and into the sight of Othello. AO3 The inevitable doom of Othello is sealed before this extract begins the extract is step one in bringing the plan into action. The willingness of Iago to manipulate anyone is revealed in the opening quotation of the extract and as he overrides Roderigo s words throughout. Iago manipulates the flaws of Othello, abusing his trust and loyalty, and poisoning his mind with fear. Iago encourages the brutality of a more bloodthirsty genre, inciting Othello to a feel a waked wrath (III.3.368) and the consequences of such an awakening. The expected catharsis is incomplete with Iago remaining silent and unwilling to give reason to his behaviour. pg 17