San Diego City Schools 2003 Redistricting

Transcription

1 San Diego City Schools 2003 Redistricting Follow up to Board Instructions July 22, 2003 National Demographics Corporation 1

2 Focus on A3 July 8 Board meeting discussion focused on plan A3 Board members requested tests of various changes The following slides provide results of those tests Street by Street, Person by Person changes in separate report Plan A3 2

3 Largest VAP Groups Current A3 A B C D E 68.2 % NH White 14.6 % Asian 64.1 % NH White 19.2 % Asian 79.9 % NH White 10.9 % Hispanic 40.3 % Hispanic 39.6 % NH White 32.7 % Hispanic, 24.6 % Asian, 21.5 % Black, 17.6 % NH White 64.2 % NH White 23.0 % Asian 68.0 % NH White 10.3 % Asian 77.0 % NH White 11.7 % Hispanic 42.3 % NH White 38.8 % Hispanic 32.7 % Hispanic, 24.6 % Asian, 21.5 % Black, 17.6 % NH White 3

4 Alternatives Created from Tests 3 shown as regionally focused rotations 3 shown as full plans 4

5 Regional Change Tests Could be added into original A3 or into other alternative plans Districts not mentioned are unchanged 5

6 July 8 Board Meeting Instructions Test D / B / C rotation Kensington into B & part of Linda Vista out of B Separate test with additional Uptown area into D 6

7 Results C OLD SAN DIEGO LINDA VISTA MISSION VALLEY COLLE 8 Y-PACIFIC HIGHWAY UPTOWN RESERVE MID-CITY:NORMAL HEIGHTS GREATER NORTH PARK MID-CITY:CITY HEIGHTS D GREATER GOLDEN HILL 94 CENTRE CITY SOUTHEASTERN SAN DIEGO,SOUTHEASTERN BARRIO LOGAN D SAN DIEGO LINDA VISTA MISSION VALLEY C 8 CIFIC HIGHWAY UPTOWN ARY FACILITIES RESERVE MID-CITY:NORMAL HEIGHTS GREATER NORTHPARK MID-CITY:CITY HEIGHT D GREATER GOLDEN HILL CENTRE CITY SOUTHEASTERN SAN DIEGO,SOUTHEASTE BARRIO LOGAN Kensington north of Meade from D to B Linda Vista west of Via Las Cumbres Hispanic VAP 39.7 % in District D Add move of C/D border from current at Curlew to Union, Kite, Hawk and Stephens Streets Hispanic VAP 39.0 % in District D 7

8 July 8 Board Meeting Instructions Test D / B / E rotation Switch SW area of E to district D E picks up areas north of current border Kensington into B 8

9 Black Population Sparse in North SW area of E is heavily Black Few areas with Black population available to north COLLEGE AREA Language Academ MID-CITY:NORMAL HEIGHTS Clay Adams Franklin Jackson Euclid k Edison Central n Rosa Parks Darnall Rolando Marshall MID-CITY:EASTERN AREA MID-CITY:CITY HEIGHTS Carver McKinley Hamilton Rowan Oak Park Webster LDEN HILL Johnson Encanto Mead Horton E ugh Chollas 94 Black VAP pct to to to to to to No Pop. Audubon EASTERN SAN DIEGO,SOUTHEASTERN 5 Bandini Baker Emerson Chavez LITARY FACILITIES Balboa Kennedy Knox Valencia Nye Perry Fulton Boone SKYLINE-PARADISE HILLS Bethune Freese Paradise Hills Zamorano Lee Penn 9

10 Result COLLEGE AREA Hisp VAP in D: Up to 40.4 % Black VAP in E: Down to 20.9 % Y:NORMAL HEIGHTS ORTH PARK MID-CITY:CITY HEIGHTS 94 E SAN DIEGO,SOUTHEASTERN AN RY FACILITIES SKYLINE-PARADISE HILLS 10

11 Unexpected Finding Kensington can be moved from District D into District B without offsetting move elsewhere District D deviation in plan A3: % Deviation with Kensington removed: % Result in plan A3 is only a 0.06 increase in total deviation, as District B deviation is already % 11

12 Full Plan Revision Tests Switch from east west to north south orientation in northern area Two different approaches Small changes in D and E included 12

13 July 8 Board Meeting Instructions Revised Plan 1 Kensington out of D North / South oriented districts in North Coastal District University triangle into Coastal District Clairemont and Linda Vista united in A Scripps Ranch stays in B 13

14 Revised 1 TORREY PINES MIRAMAR RANCH NORTH LOS PENASQUITOS CANYONPRESERVE MIRA MESA RESERVE Asian VAP in District A 22.4 % Hisp. VAP in District D 39.1 % Black VAP in District E 21.5 % Total Dev % Options to reduce deviation: Split University triangle Move A south into north edge of Old Town / Uptown Move more of Uptown to D LA JOLLA 805 UNIVERSITY 5 A 15 C 52 CLAIREMONT MESA LINDA VISTA MISSION BEACH 8 OLD SANDIEGO OCEAN BEACH MIDWAY-PACIFIC HIGHWAY RESERVE PENINSULA TIERRASANTA KEARNY MESA NAVAJO SERRA MESA MISSION VALLEY COLLEGE AREA D 163 GREATER GOLDENHILL CENTRE CITY SOUTHEASTERN SAN DIEGO,SOUTHEASTERN BARRIO LOGAN SKYLINE-PARADISE HILLS B MID-CITY:NORMAL HEIGHTS UPTOWN GREATER NORTHPARK MID-CITY:CITY HEIGHTS 94 E 14

15 July 8 Board Meeting Instructions Revised Plan 2 Kensington out of D and into B North / South oriented districts Coastal District created west of I-5 in north Clairemont united in A Scripps Ranch into B Linda Vista into C Small Talmadge area (north of El Cajon) moved from E to B 15

16 Revised 2 TORREY PINES MIRAMAR RANCH NORTH LOS PENASQUITOS CANYON PRESERVE MIRA MESA RESERVE Asian VAP in District A 22.5 % Hisp. VAP in District D 39.7 % Black VAP in District E 21.6 % Total Deviation 4.74 % LA JOLLA PACIFIC BEACH 805 UNIVERSITY A 5 15 C KEARNY MESA CLAIREMONT MESA NAVAJO SERRA MESA LINDA VISTA MISSION BEACH MISSION VALLEY COLLEGE AREA MID-CITY:NORMAL HEIGHTS 8 OLD SAN DIEGO OCEAN BEACH MIDWAY-PACIFIC HIGHWAY UPTOWN GREATER NORTH PARK MID-CITY:CITY HEIGHTS B PENINSULA RESERVE D GREATER GOLDEN HILL CENTRE CITY 94 E SOUTHEASTERN SAN DIEGO,SOUTHEASTERN BARRIO LOGAN SKYLINE-PARADISE HILLS 16

17 Revised 2B TORREY PINES MIRAMAR RANCH NORTH SW corner of Clairemont kept in District C 3,767 people south of Milton Rd. A becomes 22.9 % Asian VAP Otherwise identical to Revised 2 Total Dev % LOS PENASQUITOS CANYON PRESERVE MIRA MESA RESERVE 805 UNIVERSITY LA JOLLA PACIFIC BEACH A 5 15 C 52 CLAIREMONT MESA LINDA VISTA MISSION BEACH 8 OLD SAN DIEGO OCEAN BEACH MIDWAY-PACIFIC HIGHWAY RESERVE PENINSULA KEARNY MESA NAVAJO SERRA MESA MISSION VALLEY COLLEGE AREA D 163 B MID-CITY:NORMAL HEIGHTS UPTOWN GREATER NORTH PARK MID-CITY:CITY HEIGHTS GREATER GOLDEN HILL 94 CENTRE CITY SOUTHEASTERN SAN DIEGO,SOUTHEASTERN E S BARRIO LOGAN SKYLINE-PARADISE HILLS 17

18 San Diego City Schools 2003 Redistricting Follow up to Board Instructions July 22, 2003 National Demographics Corporation 18