Result of Technical Evaluation for Packages under IFB WB-4/703 in MPRCP (Refer Clause ITB of Bidding Document for MPRC Project)

Transcription

1 M/s Anil Construction Company, Jain Sadan Mahal Road, Shivpuri (M.P.) M/s OSHO Associates, Civil Contractor, 30, Satyadev Nagar, Gandhi Road, Gwalior (M.P.) 1 M/s D.N. Rathi Construction, Diversion Road, Opp Maruti Showroom, Guna (M.P.) M/s Siddharth Builders, Rajghat Dam Project, District Lalitpur (U.P.) M/s Bharill and Company, Gali No. 01, Ward No. 04, Lake Cily Colony, Ashoknagar (M.P.) M/s Bharill and Company, Gali No. 01, Ward No. 04, Lake Cily Colony, Ashoknagar (M.P.) 2 MP47WB14 M/s Anil Construction Company, Jain Sadan Mahal Road, Shivpuri (M.P.) 3 Ashoknagar-2 MP47WB11 M/s A.K. Shivhare Infrastructure, Biora (M.P.) 4 Chhatarpur MP06WB03 M/s Raj Laxmi Construction Dahr -3 MP11WB09 Dahr -3 MP11WB09 M/s Rameshchandra Raghuvanshi, Dhar 5 Dahr -3 MP11WB09 M/s Nirman Builders, Baroda Dahr -3 MP11WB09 M/s Shree Construction, Rajkot (Gujrat) Dahr -3 MP11WB09 M/s Vyas Associates, Sardarpur Distt. Dhar 6 Damoh MP08WB05 Shiv Kumar Tamarkar Damoh C:\Users\mprrda\Desktop\Result_Evaluation_WB4_WB5_WB6_MPRCP.xlsx 19

2 Datia MP09WB01 M/s Patel Construction Pvt.Ltd Biaora Turn Over is not equal to estimated Datia MP09WB01 M/s Anuj Tiwari, Jhansi 7 cost of the package. Datia MP09WB01 M/s Badri Prasad Mudgli, Jhansi Turn Over is not equal to estimated cost of the package. 8 9 Datia Dhar-1 MP09WB02 MP11WB03 M/s Patel Construction Pvt,Ltd Biaora M/s Shree Construction Co, Rajkot Gujrat - - Datia Dhar-1 MP09WB02 MP11WB03 M/s Osho Associates, Gwalior M/s Ramesh Chandra Raghuwanshi Dhar-1 MP11WB04 M/s Ramesh Chandra Raghuwanshi Dhar Dhar-3 MP11WB08 11 Dhar-3 MP11WB08 M/s Rajesh Agrawal, Indore as the turn over is less than PAC as per S.B.D. para 4.4 (A) (9) of I.T.B. Dhar-3 MP11WB08 M/s Niyati Construction Co. Dhar-3 MP11WB08 M/s Shree Construction, Rajkot (Gujrat) 12 Gwalior MP14WB01 M.s Kushwa Construction Company Gtwlaior 13 Gwalior MP14WB02 M/s Osho Associates, Gwalior (M.P) Gwalior MP14WB02 M/s Ravindra Singh Tomar, Gwalior (M.P) 14 Gwalior MP14WB04 M/s Ravindra Singh Tomar, Gwalior (MP.P) 15 Hoshangabad MP16WB12 M/s sanjaya Paliya Contractor Prop. SMt Jayehree Paliya 16 Hoshangabad MP16WB11 M/s Jyoti Construction Company Harda No Submission Due to Not submitted of certificate for similar singal work, Bank certificate for financing & work Methodology. 17 Katni MP20WB01 M/s Gyanendra Tiwari Single Similar Nature of Work is less then 50% of estimated Cost of Package. 18 Katni MP20WB05 M/s Axle Engineering Pvt. Ltd. 19 Katni MP20WB06 M/s Axle Engineering Pvt. Ltd. C:\Users\mprrda\Desktop\Result_Evaluation_WB4_WB5_WB6_MPRCP.xlsx 29

3 Katni MP20WB07 M/s Axle Engineering Pvt. Ltd. 20 Katni MP20WB07 M/s MNS Infratech Balance Sheet attached is not signed by C.A. Katni MP20WB07 Smt. Chitra Sharma For short EMD Amount. 21 Morena MP25WB06 M/s Bhagwati Enterprizes Morena Morena MP25WB07 Kushwaha Construction Company Gwalior Bid capacity not meet out as per 22 Morena MP25WB07 Kushwaha Construction Company Jagdalpur bidding document clause 4.6 of Sec. 2 of ITB Morena MP25WB07 M/s Bhagwati Enterprizes Morena Morena MP25WB07 Dandotia Construction Compnay Neemuch MP27WB04 M/s Ankita Construction 22, Sawariya colony Nimbahera Dist, Chhittogarh (Raj) 23 Chetak Interprises LTd 396/11Hiran Magari, Neemuch MP27WB04 udapur (Raj) Neemuch MP27WB04 Nalwaya Construction Udaipur 24 Neemuch MP27WB06 M/s Ankita Construction 22, Sawariya colony Nimbahera Dist, Chhittogarh (Raj) Raisen -2 MP29WB19 M/s R.K. Construction Dewas 25 Raisen -2 MP29WB19 M/s Santosh Rai JCB, Raisen Value of singal similar nature of work executed is less than the required Raisen -2 MP29WB19 M/s Supreme Buildcon Pvt Ltd. Bhopal 26 Raisen -2 MP29WB20 M/s R.K. Construction Dewas 27 Raisen -2 MP29WB21 M/s Dilip Singh Raghuwanshi Rajgarh MP30WB01 M/s Jagdish Verma Rajgarh MP30WB01 M/s Patel Construction Biaora Pvt. Ltd. 28 Rajgarh MP30WB01 M/s Ram Prasad Dangi Rajgarh MP30WB01 Rajgarh MP30WB02 M/s Jagdish Verma 29 Rajgarh MP30WB02 M/s Shri Hari Guru Kripa Construction C:\Users\mprrda\Desktop\Result_Evaluation_WB4_WB5_WB6_MPRCP.xlsx 39

4 29 Rajgarh MP30WB02 Rajgarh MP30WB07 M/s RAJMARG BUILDERS & INFRASTRUCTURE 30 Rajgarh MP30WB07 M/s YUVRAJ INFRA BIAORA Rajgarh MP30WB07 M/s Radheshyam Sondhiya Rajgarh MP30WB07 M/s Patel Construction Biaora Pvt. Ltd. Rajgarh MP30WB07 M/s Vinayak Construction Company Due to less turn over 31 Rajgarh MP30WB08 M/s Rajlaxmi Construction Guna Rajgarh MP30WB08 M/s A.K.Shivhare Infrastructure Pvt.Ltd. Rajgarh MP30WB09 M/s YUVRAJ INFRA BIAORA 32 Rajgarh MP30WB09 M/s Ram Prasad Dangi Rajgarh MP30WB09 M/s Patel Construction Biaora Pvt. Ltd. Rajgarh MP30WB09 Govardha Singh Dangi Due to less turn over 33 Rajgarh MP30WB13 M/s Ram Prasad Dangi Rajgarh MP30WB13 Balveer Construction 34 Sagar-1 MP33WB08 M/s Ashok Kumar Jain 35 Sagar-1 MP33WB10 M/s Tulsi Narayan Garg 36 Sagar-1 MP33WB12 M/s CBS Construction Company 37 Satna MP34WB08 M/s ABC associates, Satna Satna MP34WB08 M/s Swapnil Singh, Satna 38 Shajapur MP39WB14 M/s Karada Construction Company, Indore Shajapur MP39WB17 M/s Rajendra Kumar Agrawal, Shujalpur Shajapur Shajapur MP39WB17 M/s Arun Kumar Kayal, Shujalpur Shajapur Shajapur MP39WB17 M/s Prabhunath Singh, Shujalpur Shajapur Shajapur MP39WB18 M/s Phalodi Construction and infrastructure Pvt. Ltd., Indore Shajapur MP39WB18 Amcon Construction Company Sheopur MP37WB01 M/s Tulsi Narayan Garg Sheopur MP37WB01 M/s Laxmi Chand Company, Gwalior 15% liquidity not avaliable C:\Users\mprrda\Desktop\Result_Evaluation_WB4_WB5_WB6_MPRCP.xlsx 49

5 42 43 Sheopur MP37WB01 M/s Laxmi Narayan Agrawal, Jaipur Black listed by MPRRDA Tikamgarh MP42WB03 M/s Divine Infra Structure Tikamgarh MP42WB03 M/s R.S. Construction Vidisha-2 MP45WB14 M/s Dilip Singh Raghuwanshi, Vidisha (M.P.) Vidisha-2 MP45WB14 M/s A.K.Shivhare Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd., Bioara (M.P.) 44 Vidisha-2 MP45WB17 M/s Dilip Singh Raghuwanshi, Vidisha (M.P.) 45 Vidisha-2 MP45WB19 M/s Raghu Devlopers, Vidisha (M.P.) Vidisha-2 MP45WB19 M/s ANV Construction Company, 17, Windsor Estate Chuna Bhatti, Kolar Raod, Bhopal (M.P.) C:\Users\mprrda\Desktop\Result_Evaluation_WB4_WB5_WB6_MPRCP.xlsx 59

6 Result of Technical Evaluation of Packages under IFB WB-5/704 in MPRCP 1 Ashoknagar-2 MP47WB12 M/s Siddhart Builders, Lalitpur, (U.P.) 2 Bhopal MP05WB02 M/s Vikas Shivhare Bhopal MP05WB02 M/s Kushalguru Construction Co. Dhar-3 MP11WB10 3 Dhar-3 MP11WB10 M/s Rameshchandra Raghuvanshi, Dhar 4 Dhar-3 MP11WB12 Neemuch MP27WB05 M/s Ankita Construction 22, Sawariya colony Nimbahera Dist, Chhittogarh (Raj) 5 Chetak Interprises LTd 396/11Hiran Magari, Neemuch MP27WB05 udapur (Raj) Neemuch MP27WB05 Nalwaya Construction Udaipur Neemuch MP27WB07 M/s Ankita Construction 22, Sawariya colony Nimbahera Dist, Chhittogarh (Raj) 6 Neemuch MP27WB07 Nathulal Patidar, Gram Knawati Dist Neemuch Neemuch MP27WB07 MVS Infrastructure Ltd Manasa Disst Neemuch 7 Rajgarh MP30WB03 M/s Shri Hari Guru Kripa Construction Due to less turn over 8 Rajgarh MP30WB05 M/s RAJMARG BUILDERS & INFRASTRUCTURE Rajgarh MP30WB05 NANDRAM MALAKAR Due to less turn over and Liquid Assets Rajgarh MP30WB11 M/s Radheshyam Sondhiya 9 Rajgarh MP30WB11 M/s A.K.Shivhare Infrastructure Pvt.Ltd. Rajgarh MP30WB11 M/s ANV Construction Company Rajgarh MP30WB11 M/s Patel Construction Biaora Pvt. Ltd. 10 Rajgarh MP30WB14 M/s Patel Construction Biaora Pvt. Ltd. Rajgarh MP30WB15 M/s ANV Construction Company

7 Result of Technical Evaluation of Packages under IFB WB-5/704 in MPRCP 11 Rajgarh MP30WB15 M/s A.K.Shivhare Infrastructure Pvt.Ltd. Rajgarh MP30WB15 M/s Ram Prasad Dangi Rajgarh MP30WB15 M/s Patel Construction Biaora Pvt. Ltd. 12 Sagar 1 MP33WB11 M/s Tulsi Narayan Garg 13 Sagar 1 MP33WB13 M/s Jinendra Kumar Jain 14 Shajapur MP39WB15 M/s Mahendra Singh Sonti Turnover deficient Maximum turnover Rs lacs. Estimated cost of Rs lacs. 15 Shajapur MP39WB19 M/s Krishna Construction, 16 Sheopur MP37WB02 M/s Tulsi Narayan Garg 17 Vidisha-2 MP45WB015 M/s Dilip Singh Raghuwanshi, Vidisha (M.P.) 18 Vidisha-2 MP45WB018 M/s Dilip Singh Raghuwanshi, Vidisha (M.P.) 19 Vidisha-2 MP45WB020 M/s Dilip Singh Raghuwanshi, Vidisha (M.P.) Vidisha-2 MP45WB020 M/s Mangal Singh Rajput, Basoda Dist. Vidisha (M.P.)

8 Result of Technical Evaluation for Packages under IFB WB-6/705 in MPRCP Dhar-3 MP11WB13 Dhar-3 MP11WB13 M/s Orion Construction Pvt. Ltd. Neemuch MP27WB08 Nathulal Patidar, Gram Knawati Dist Neemuch Neemuch MP27WB08 MVS Infrastructure Ltd Manasa Disst Neemuch Rajgarh MP30WB04 M/s Shri Hari Guru Kripa Construction Rajgarh MP30WB04 Rajgarh MP30WB06 M/s RAJMARG BUILDERS & INFRASTRUCTURE Rajgarh MP30WB06 M/s Patel Construction Biaora Pvt. Ltd. Rajgarh MP30WB06 5 Rajgarh MP30WB12 M/s A.K.Shivhare Infrastructure Pvt.Ltd. Rajgarh MP30WB12 6 Rajgarh MP30WB16 M/s A.K.Shivhare Infrastructure Pvt.Ltd. 7 Rajgarh MP30WB18 M/s A.K.Shivhare Infrastructure Pvt.Ltd. Rajgarh MP30WB18 M/s Patel Construction Biaora Pvt. Ltd.

9 Result of Technical Evaluation for Packages under IFB WB-6/705 in MPRCP Shajapur-1 MP39WB16 M/s Anil Kumar Agrawal, Shujalpur Shajapur 1)Turnover deficient Maximun turnover Rs lacs. Estimated cost of Rs lacs. 2) Bid capacity deficient Calculated Bid capacity Rs lacs. Estimated cost of work Rs lacs. 8 Shajapur-1 MP39WB16 M/s Shiv Shakti Shajapur 1)Turnover deficient Maximun turnover Rs lacs. Estimated cost of Rs lacs. 2) Similar work of nature deficient Shwon in document Rs lacs (work particulars not given) Required Rs lacs. 9 Vidisha-2 MP45WB16 M/s A.K.Shivhare Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd., Bioara (M.P.) Vidisha-2 MP45WB21 M/s Raghu Developers, Vidisha (M.P.) 10 M/s ANV Construction Company, 17, Vidisha-2 MP45WB21 Windsor Estate Chuna Bhatti, Kolar Raod, Bhopal (M.P.)