TYNDP 2016 public consultation

Transcription

1 TYNDP 2016 public consultation Overview ENTSO E aims with this consultation to get feedback on: CURRENT TYNDP 2016 < main report and the associated 12 Insight Reports FUTURE TYNDP 2018 what shall we consider when building it. Why we are consulting ENTSO E consults the TYNDP for three main reasons: the future is developed by all of us and there is no one clearly defined path to reach it developing suitable grid solutions that stands these posibilites is key planning and building the transmission infrastrure needs all of us to materialise public acceptance impeds 25% of the pan European projects to realise on time present the information in a format and at a level that can be used not only by the experts but by all of us. Identification 1 What is your name? Name 2 What is your address? This is optional, but if you enter your address then you will be able to return to edit your consultation at any time until you submit it. You will also receive an acknowledgement when you complete the consultation. development/tyndp 2016 public consultation/consultation/print_survey 1/15

2 3 What is your organisation? Organisation Introduction This consultation has 4 main parts (three for the TYNDP 2016 and one for TYNDP 2018). In order to answer any of the reports you can click on the report and you'll be redirected to the questions related to it. You can always return to this page from the reports consultation details. You can give us feedback on all or only on some of the reports. Your feedback will be used to: 1. Improve the current TYNDP 2016 < which ENTSO E will deliver to ACER in October 2016 and publish as final end December Design and improve the TYNDP 2018 process and deliverables. Related Information Links to all the TYNDP 2016 reports TYNDP 2016 Executive Summary < report/> TYNDP 2016 Insight reports < reports/> : A push for Projects of Common Interest Baltic Synchronization Data and expertise as key ingredients Focus on the Nordic and Baltic Sea Future system perspectives North Seas regional planning North South Interconnections in Central East and South East Europe North South interconnections in Western Europe regional planning Stakeholder engagement Technologies for Transmission System The link between system adequacy and the TYNDP Viability of the energy mix development/tyndp 2016 public consultation/consultation/print_survey 2/15

3 4 Please select the report you want to give feedback to. Note: after you finish with the questions from one report you will be redirected (if wished so) to the other reports you want to comment. TYNDP 2016 general questions TYNDP 2016 Executive Summary TYNDP 2016 Insight reports A push for Projects of Common Interest TYNDP 2016 Insight reports Baltic Synchronization TYNDP 2016 Insight reports Data and expertise as key ingredients TYNDP 2016 Insight reports Focus on the Nordic and Baltic Sea TYNDP 2016 Insight reports Future system perspectives TYNDP 2016 Insight reports North Seas regional planning TYNDP 2016 Insight reports North South Interconnections in Central East and South East Europe TYNDP 2016 Insight reports North South interconnections in Western Europe regional planning TYNDP 2016 Insight reports Stakeholder engagement TYNDP 2016 Insight reports Technologies for Transmission System TYNDP 2016 Insight reports The link between system adequacy and the TYND TYNDP 2016 Insight reports Viability of the energy mix TYNDP 2018 questions TYNDP general questions 5 Is the TYNDP 2016 easy to read and navigate through? Yes No 6 Do you like the idea of having a main report and individual thematic insight reports? Yes No development/tyndp 2016 public consultation/consultation/print_survey 3/15

4 7 Are the graphs, maps and tables easy to understand? Yes No 8 Do you find the information presented in the TYNDP usefull to you? Yes No 9 What value do you see in providing a very long term perspective (e.g. 2050) in future TYNDPs? What type of results are valuable to you from this perspective? 10 Do you want to give us further feedback? Questions on the TYNDP 2016 Executive Summary Before answering to the questions below we kindly invite you to read the TYNDP 2016 Executive Summary which can be accesed here < report/>. development/tyndp 2016 public consultation/consultation/print_survey 4/15

5 11 A planning exercise covers scenario development, identification of needs, projects and CBA assessment. After reading the report which elements, require from your perspective additional explanation and which are we totally missing? Require more/better explanation Currently not addressed but shall be in the future 12 Each of the TYNDP project comes with a 3 4 page explanation document which incorporates the project description, the need it mitigates, the CBA assessment results and further information. What is your view about this new approach of presenting the TYNDP projects? What is your personal insight gained from the CBA results? Are the results relevant to you? How can we further improve? development/tyndp 2016 public consultation/consultation/print_survey 5/15

6 13 Does the TYNDP 2016 incorporate the relevant information for an informed decision? If not what shall it include in addition? 14 Other comments/suggestions not covered by the above questions 15 Insight report A push for Projects of Common Interest This report answers questions like: Why Europe needs an infrastructure push even with more local generation, storage and demand response? Is Europe regulation on infrastructure delivering its promise? What could be done differently to ease the building of priority projects? Insight report A push for Projects of Common Interest can be accessed here < projects/> development/tyndp 2016 public consultation/consultation/print_survey 6/15

7 Insight report Baltic Synchronization The report looks into: How to integrate further the Baltic countries in the European power system? What about the desynchronisation with the Russian power system? What infratsructure solutions for a secure and competitive Baltic power system? The full report can be accesed here. < reports/baltic synchronisation/> Insigh Report Data and expertise as key ingredients The TYNDP is an open process. This report will give you the list of data sources and tools used by the ENTSO E experts to make the TYNDP and what you can freely access to support your own research. The full report can be access here < reports/data and expertise/>. < reports/data and expertise/> development/tyndp 2016 public consultation/consultation/print_survey 7/15

8 Insight report Focus on the Nordic and Baltic Sea The report is looking at what is driving grid development in the Nordic and Baltic Sea region: integration of the Baltic power systems, enabling North to South power flows along with the Impact of planned nuclear decommissioning in Sweden and Finland. The full report can be accessed here. < reports/nordic baltic sea/> Insight report Future system perspectives The report answers questions like: Where does one start to plan nerwork development 15 years ahead? How to make sure the assumptions used are realistic and at the same time future looking enough? How to broaden the scope of possibilities but maintain a sufficient level of feasibility? Learn how long term grid planning is done in the TYNDP. The full report can be accessed < reports/future system/> here < reports/future system/>. < reports/future system/> development/tyndp 2016 public consultation/consultation/print_survey 8/15

9 Insight report North Seas regional planning The report answers questions like:what congestions is the TYNDP tackling in the North Sea regions? What progress for the North Sea Offshore Grid? What about a new long term West East corridor? The full report can be accessed here. < reports/north seas/> Insight report North South Interconnections in Central East and South East Europe The report looks into what it takes to building power bridges between Eastern and Western Europe; relieving the bottlenecks in Central Europe; see what grid development the Central East and the South East regions are facing. The full report can be accessed here. < reports/north south interconnection cee see/> development/tyndp 2016 public consultation/consultation/print_survey 9/15

10 Insight report North South interconnections in Western Europe regional planning The report answers quetions like: How to plan a grid to manage connection of large renewable plants in the North and in the South? How to move large quantities of renewables accross long distances? See how the energy transition is game changing network development in Western Europe. The full report can be accessed here. < reports/north south interconnection western/> Insight report Stakeholder engagement The TYNDP is a collective exercise. The quality of its output very much depends on ENTSO E's ability to engage as early and as extensively as possible with all parties that have an interest in how the power grid is designed. Learn how ENTSO E did it in 2016 and how it plans to increase participation in The full report can be accessed here. < reports/engagement/> 32 development/tyndp 2016 public consultation/consultation/print_survey 10/15

11 33 Are you aware of the activities of the Network Development Stakeholder Group? What are your views about it? 34 What action from ENTSO E side could have improved your interaction with us along the TYNDP 2016 development? 35 In what area(s) has the ENTSO E stakeholders interaction been of special value to you? 36 Insight report Technologies for Transmission System Current advances in technology offer project promoters many opportunities to implement new solutions to cope with future network development, which is defined in the TYNDP. Together with current technologies, innovative technologies will be incorporated with the existing infrastructure. These technologies have their own learning curves and innovation cycles. Project promotors, regulators and policy makers need to understand something of each technology and their availability by the time of project development. The full report can be accessed here. < reports/technology/> development/tyndp 2016 public consultation/consultation/print_survey 11/15

12 37 38 Insight report The link between system adequacy and the TYNDP The report into answering questions like: Are there risk to Europe's pan European adequacy in the next five to ten years? Why is it important to assess adequacy the possibility for a system to meet demand in all conditions at a pan European scale? What methodology is ENTSO E using and does it cater for the rapid change in Europe's generation mix? The full report can be accessed here. < reports/system ad/> Insight report Viability of the energy mix The energy mix has been and is facing significant changes accross Europe, with a signficant increase of production of electricity from renewable sources. While it lead to significant reduction of CO2 emissions of the power sector, it creates some additional challenges both from the technical and economic point of view that are being described further in this Insight Report. The full report can be accessed here. < reports/energy mix/> development/tyndp 2016 public consultation/consultation/print_survey 12/15

13 41 42 TYNDP 2018 questions With each cycle ENTSO E, based on your input and its internal learning, is constantly improving the TYNDP processes, methodologies, outcomes and overall stakeholder interaction. Currently we are at a very early stage in the TYNDP 2018 building and your input (by answering the questions below) will help us better shape the future reports. development/tyndp 2016 public consultation/consultation/print_survey 13/15

14 43 Imagine for a moment that you are the Gepetto of the European TYNDP 2018, you create it from the beginning and drive through your planning exercise. How would your TYNDP look like in terms of structure? How would your TYNDP look like in terms of content? How would your TYNDP look like in terms of results presentation? What new technologies and developments with regard to system planning do you consider relevant for the future? How would your European TYNDP be used and for what? development/tyndp 2016 public consultation/consultation/print_survey 14/15

15 How and when the stakeholders would be involved in the process? How would you promote and to whom the final outcomes? 44 development/tyndp 2016 public consultation/consultation/print_survey 15/15